Poem #10: Stranger — Poem analysis

Jane OdairContemplative

Somehow, Just somehow, Telling my secrets to you, A stranger, A complete stranger, Is gratifying, Telling my worries to you, A stranger, A complete stranger, Calms them, Somehow confiding in you, A stranger, A complete stranger, Makes it hurt less

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

We are usually told that the best person to confide in is someone who knows us well. Jane Odair's "Poem #10: Stranger" quietly argues the opposite. Its speaker finds that handing over secrets, worries and hurts is easier, and more soothing, when the listener is "a complete stranger." The poem never says why, and that missing explanation is part of what makes it worth reading closely.

The construction is simple enough to see at a glance. After a two-line opening ("Somehow, / Just somehow,"), the poem repeats one four-line pattern three times. Something is told to "you," the listener is named as "A stranger, / A complete stranger," and a verb delivers the effect. There is no rhyme and no regular metre, so the music comes from repetition. The refrain also changes shape as it goes. "A stranger" is a short, three-syllable phrase, and "A complete stranger" nearly doubles it. The second line sounds like the speaker insisting, or perhaps reassuring themselves, that the distance really is total.

The poem is also carefully graded. What gets told moves from "secrets" to "worries" to something with no object at all: "Somehow confiding in you" simply trails off, as though the content no longer matters, only the act of telling. The effects move in step with this. First comes something that is "gratifying," then something that "Calms them," and finally something that "Makes it hurt less." Secrets are things we hide, worries are things we dread, and "hurt" is something we already feel. The poem travels from the mind's private storeroom to the body's ache. In that last line, "it" has no antecedent, so the pain stays unnamed, and the poem never says what exactly hurts.

The word choices repay attention. "Gratifying" is a slightly formal, almost clinical word, and it hints at a satisfaction the speaker may not be entirely comfortable with. "Calms them" treats worries as restless things that can be soothed, a little like animals. And the final claim is modest. The stranger does not cure the pain or make it stop; it hurts "less." That restraint makes the poem believable. A more dramatic ending would have sounded like a fantasy of rescue.

There is a tension in the pronouns, too. "You" is the most intimate way to address anyone, yet the poem keeps attaching it to a label of distance. The speaker speaks as to a close friend while insisting, three times over, that the listener is nothing of the kind. The poem leaves the reason unspoken, but the logic seems to be that someone with no history with us cannot judge us by it, and will not be waiting at the next family dinner. That is an inference, though, not something the text states. What the text does give us is the speaker's own bafflement. "Somehow" opens the poem, is doubled by "Just somehow," and returns at the start of the final unit. The speaker does not claim to understand the effect, only to have noticed it. "Just somehow" sounds like a shrug, as if explaining it might spoil it.

The punctuation adds to this. Every line ends in a comma except the last, which ends with nothing at all. The commas make the poem feel like a halting confession, one admission after another, with no full stop allowed. The missing final punctuation leaves the relief open-ended. The hurt is lessened, not closed.

The poem's significance lies in how small and exact it is. It does not tell a story or name a stranger, and it offers no scene such as a train or a waiting room. That emptiness lets nearly any reader slot in their own memory of saying too much to someone they would never see again. The numbered title suggests the poem may belong to a larger group, but it stands perfectly well alone. It also catches the reader in its own idea. A poem confiding private feelings to an audience it has never met is itself an act of telling a stranger, and the reader is the stranger whose listening is meant to make it hurt less.

Read also

More by Jane Odair

All poems
SadJane Odair

Poem #25: Every Day

Every day is exactly the same, I get up and get dressed, I talk to all the people who secretly hate me, I drone on through school,