«There's something I'd like to wish…» — Poem analysis

There's something I'd like to wish To the people I cherish At the starless sky I see tonight, to the lonely rock reflecting light

This is not a goodbye letter If that will make you feel better Killing myself won't help me Or others for that matter

I just wish for whoever reads this —to look towards the future Not necessarily in a positive way But to see you live a bit more futher

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A title as offhand as "I'm actually gay as hell" sounds like a joke or a shrug. Then, after the small typographic pause of «* * *», the poem drops into a much quieter register: someone under a dark sky, making a wish for the people they love. Nothing in the text explains how title and verse connect, so any reading is inference. It could be a casual, everyday voice carrying something heavy, or a mask of ease slipping. Either way, the distance between the two is the first thing a reader has to cross.

The central idea is survival without a promise of happiness. The speaker opens by heading off a fear: "This is not a goodbye letter / If that will make you feel better." The second line is double-edged. It can be read as genuine consideration, since the speaker is managing the reader's worry, or as a faintly weary aside. Then comes the bluntest sentence in the poem: "Killing myself won't help me / Or others for that matter." The phrase "for that matter" is the tone of a casual conversation, almost a debating point, and it sits oddly against such a grave subject. That flatness is the poem's strength. The speaker doesn't dramatise, which makes the statement feel like something reasoned through rather than performed.

The imagery is sparse but carefully chosen. The wish is made "at the starless sky," which quietly overturns the old habit of wishing on a star. With no stars available, the wish goes to "the lonely rock reflecting light." The moon is never named, and calling it a rock strips away its romance. The detail that matters is that the rock gives no light of its own. It only reflects. Judging by the imagery, that could hint at how a person gets through a dark stretch: by returning light that comes from somewhere else, such as the "people I cherish" of the opening lines. "Cherish" is the warmest word in the poem, and it appears right beside the darkest sky.

The sound pattern loosens as the poem goes on. The first stanza is tidy: "wish" chimes with "cherish," "tonight" with "light." The second leans on one repeated sound, "letter," "better," "matter," while "me" stands slightly apart. By the third stanza almost nothing rhymes, apart from a near-echo between "future" and "futher," presumably meant as "further." The rhythm follows suit. Lines hover around seven or eight syllables without a fixed metre, and the third stanza stretches into longer, more prose-like lines. The form seems to relax as the speaker grows more direct, and the rough edges, such as the lowercase "to" opening line four and the misspelling, make the voice feel unpolished and unguarded.

The last stanza holds the poem's most interesting move. The speaker turns from "whoever reads this" to a direct "you," and what they ask for is deliberately small: "Not necessarily in a positive way." There is no demand to feel hopeful, only to "look towards the future" and "live a bit more futher." Notice "a bit more." The wish is for another stretch of time, not a cure. The near-merging of "future" and "futher" on the page suggests the two are almost the same thing here: the future is simply further along.

That modesty is what makes the poem significant. It refuses both melodrama and forced cheerfulness, and it speaks to a reader in pain as an equal rather than as a lecturer. Many texts on this subject insist that things will get better, but this one asks only for endurance, which may feel more believable to someone who can't picture feeling better yet. If the poem's mood feels close to home, it's worth telling a trusted adult, a friend, or a counsellor, which is the same kind of reaching toward "the people I cherish" that the speaker models.

Read also

More by I'm actually gay as hell

All poems
SadI'm actually gay as hell

* * *

This guilty feeling I can't wash off Not something I can easily payoff Closed the door to social life Tied myself up and for tangled in vines
RomanticI'm actually gay as hell

* * *

Hold me close and whisper in my ear Comfort me with sweet empty words Tell me you love me even if it a lie Keep your secrets from me if you want
AngryI'm actually gay as hell

* * *

'You're too old to be comforted' they said like as though they did before 'You made me like this' I told them back my emotions finally spilling You made fun of my expressions and now look at what you've done My face is tungsten but my heart is alloy