Monster — Poem analysis

LarryContemplative

They say we all look beautiful But really what's inside They say that when you live you die Or is it when you die you live They say we are alive They say that when you die you've lived a happy life Or is it when you die you've been cut free to fly They say that monsters don't exist, but really that's a lie Maybe deep down in our bones a monster lives inside It's connected to our soul, even when we die maybe it's the cutting string that let us start out flight Maybe it's the monster, that showed us what is light From what look up to as death, maybe it is life

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Almost everyone in Larry's "Monster" is quoting someone else. "They say" begins five of the poem's thirteen lines, and each time it delivers a ready-made piece of wisdom: we all look beautiful, we are alive, a good death means a happy life, monsters don't exist. The speaker refuses to swallow any of it whole. By the final lines the voice has moved from "they say" to "maybe," from borrowed certainty to personal guesswork, and that shift is the real story of the poem.

The opening shows how it works. "They say we all look beautiful / But really what's inside" trails off without finishing its thought, as if the speaker can't yet say what is inside. The answer is held back until line nine: "a monster lives inside." In between, the poem flips life and death like a coin. "When you live you die / Or is it when you die you live" is a neat reversal, and "Or is it" invites the reader to doubt the first version. The same move returns in lines six and seven, where a "happy life" gives way to being "cut free to fly." Each time, the comfortable phrase is swapped for one with movement and release in it.

Line eight is the first to speak outright: "They say that monsters don't exist, but really that's a lie." It is the only moment where "they say" is flatly contradicted, and its "but really" echoes line two. From here the monster stops being a bedtime-story creature and moves into the body: "deep down in our bones," "connected to our soul." It is physical and spiritual at once, and it outlasts the body ("even when we die"). It isn't cast as a villain, either. The speaker's guess is that it might be "the cutting string" and the thing that "showed us what is light," as if brightness could only be recognised against something dark. The cutting string is the most intriguing image. Judging by "cut free to fly" earlier, it suggests a kite or balloon being released, so the monster would be what severs us from whatever held us down. The line says "start out flight," which most likely means "our flight," and the word "start" hints at birth as much as death.

There is no fixed meter. The lines tend to grow longer as the poem goes on, and with almost no end punctuation it reads like thinking out loud. What holds it together is sound. A long "i" runs through the key words: inside, die, life, alive, lie, fly, light, flight. Several of these pair up at crucial moments. "Fly" sits right beside "lie" in lines seven and eight, so the denied monster and the promise of flight are literal neighbours. "Flight" and "light" form the next pair, and "inside" and "die" tie the monster to mortality. "Life" ends line six and is also the poem's last word, but its meaning has changed. The first is what "they say" you earn, and the second is the speaker's own hesitant claim.

The final line, "From what look up to as death, maybe it is life," has a grammatical slip (it wants a "we"), yet "look up to" does double duty. It means to revere, but it also suggests raising your eyes toward the sky where something set free would rise. The poem ends on "maybe" rather than "is," and that hedge keeps it honest. It will not replace one set of confident sayings with another.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it takes a childhood figure and puts it to an adult question. It doesn't tell us to ignore the monster or defeat it. It asks whether the frightening part of us might be what gives life and death their shape, and what lets us see light and begin to fly. The words are plain and the structure loose, but the repeated "They say" and "Maybe" give the argument a clear path, from what we are told to what we might, tentatively, believe for ourselves.

Read also

More by Larry

All poems
SadLarry

Fade

When I see you walking by With your own little lamp To see forward While I stay behind
AnxiousLarry

Achieve

If I could feel the way it feels To make them all say wow If I could just change, it would change The screaming in my head won't stop
SadLarry

Loving Myself

"Do you love yourself?" I ask myself, but never can I answer I don't know Some days I'm fine