The Open Hand and the Closed Fist — Summary

Max ReifContemplative

The open hand said to the closed fist: “Try this!”

The closed fist said: “Afraid.”

The open hand said, “You’ll be part of Everything!” The closed fist replied, “Inside my cave I must yet cling.”

Open Hand: “Are you clenched in anger?” Closed Fist: “Deep down, it’s more like hunger.”

The open hand implored, “You’ll do yourself damage if you hit!” The fist replied, “I’m not really aggressive. For protection I do this.”

The open hand then said, “I’m sad because you’re blind. The lovely world you cannot see.” The closed fist answered, “For right now, my business is with me.”

The Open Hand: But oh— If you could see as I— and parallel the sky!”

The Closed Fist: “My cavern is my safety and my need. I’m like a buried, deeply-dreaming seed.

Some day I’ll open naturally. Can you wait and see?

You are open now my friend, but you were once like me.”

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Two parts of one body argue in this poem: an open hand that wants to share the world, and a closed fist that isn't ready. The hand is eager and a little pushy. It offers connection, warns of harm, and grieves that the fist can't see the sky. The fist never attacks back. It admits it is afraid, and that beneath its clenched look is hunger, not anger. Its tight grip is protection.

The mood is gentle and quietly tense, helped by the simple, nursery-like rhymes. The fist's final image, a buried seed dreaming in the dark, changes how we see it. Closing up becomes a stage of growth, not a failure. Then the fist makes its sharpest point: the hand was once closed too. The poem seems to say that openness can't be forced, and that people who are guarded deserve patience and time.

Read also

More by Max Reif

All poems
ContemplativeMax Reif

After Sri Lanka

So many live in such desperation, they believe mass murder will solve their problems
ContemplativeMax Reif

Cities

I’m working on a major work on cities To tell people they are all the same, and different— That we live through these cities
DreamyMax Reif

Music History

I played arpeggios for Mrs. Aranda, who smelled so good and came to our house every week. Her own house had