Music History — Summary

Max ReifDreamy

I played arpeggios for Mrs. Aranda, who smelled so good and came to our house every week. Her own house had a giant blue vase on the stone front porch. I’d pass it on long walks. One time I saw her tall dark son, who had a different last name and wore black leather jackets to our school.

I learned “Stardust” by heart, and for some mysterious reason it remains in my fingers today. Everything else I played — Chopin’s Nocturne, Tschaikovsky’s Concerto in E Flat Minor, “The Poor People of Paris” — has turned to memory dust.

I hated practicing. Once, when she came for my lesson, I hid. When caught, I refused to play scales. We fought to a draw. She left; and I pined for her perfume and pretty face.

Not long after, Dad would drive my brother and me to doughty, rouge-faced Miss Gilbert’s in a drab duplex in the city. We took turns at the upright, half an hour each, while someone we never got to see shuffled in the next room, hidden by a green curtain.

I requested popular songs: when given “Theme from My Three Sons,” I played it, shameless but bored.

By the time I was twelve my folks gave up. I was free to roam baseball fields until the sun went down.

Today I tell parents of children I teach how happy I am that I learned music fundamentals as a child. And the funny thing is, it’s true.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The speaker looks back on childhood piano lessons, first with Mrs. Aranda, whom he remembers fondly for her perfume and pretty face, then with the stern Miss Gilbert. He admits he hated practicing and was often rebellious or bored, hiding from one teacher and playing a silly TV theme for the other. Most of the pieces he worked on have faded, except "Stardust," which stays in his fingers for no clear reason. The tone is gently humorous and a little wistful, full of small, sharp details like the blue vase and the unseen figure behind the green curtain.

The ending turns the memory around. Now a music teacher himself, the speaker tells parents he is glad he learned the fundamentals as a child. "And the funny thing is, it's true." That line carries the poem's mood: a wry surprise that the lessons he resisted did matter after all.

Read also

More by Max Reif

All poems
ContemplativeMax Reif

After Sri Lanka

So many live in such desperation, they believe mass murder will solve their problems
ContemplativeMax Reif

The Hitch-Hiker

The hitch-hiker I remember best was someone you might call a hobo.