«He doesn't smile at me like he used too…» — Poem analysis

He doesn't smile at me like he used too He doesn't enjoy our time together anymore He doesn't save my pictures, not even the best ones. In the beginning he was who I wanted and he showed me that he wanted me, but now I feel like he doesn't care As if I was a piece of plastic that he found and kept until he found a recycling bin As if this was a game for him Who can crumble the other first? Who can pin the mess on the problem? There's not much more I can give him. I've given him my trust, love and loyalty. The younger me would look and be disgusted with myself today After all the insults, lies and manipulation I don't know how long I can fight for a future that doesn't have a chance to survive.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Some poems announce their sadness with big images. This one builds it from small, ordinary absences. A smile that has stopped, time together that has lost its pleasure, and a detail that stings more than it should: "He doesn't save my pictures, not even the best ones." The phrase "the best ones" suggests the speaker has chosen which photos deserve keeping and has watched them be ignored anyway. The poem is about a relationship in which affection has turned into indifference and then into something worse, and about the speaker realising that continuing to give may no longer make sense.

The opening is built on repetition. Three lines begin "He doesn't," and the pattern works like a list of evidence, each item a little more painful than the last. The poem has no title (only asterisks), and no rhyme or regular rhythm. Lines are as long or short as the thought needs, so it reads like speech, or like a message typed out in one go. That plainness suits the subject. The speaker isn't performing; they're explaining. The line "I feel like he doesn't care" is the flattest in the poem, and its bluntness is the point. After the detailed evidence, the conclusion needs no decoration.

The imagery arrives in two bursts. The first is the plastic simile: the speaker is "a piece of plastic that he found and kept until he found a recycling bin." It is unflattering and exact. Plastic is cheap and has no particular value, and it is held onto only until a convenient place to get rid of it turns up. The image suggests that the speaker is not hated, just disposable, which can feel worse. The second burst is the language of games: "Who can crumble the other first? / Who can pin the mess on the problem?" The questions make the relationship a contest with no winner, where both people are trying to damage the other or avoid blame. The second question seems to echo the idiom "pin the blame," though here the blame is attached to "the mess" and "the problem," as if the two people have stopped being people and become each other's faults.

The poem's movement is quieter than its images. Early on, "he" is the grammatical subject of nearly every line. After "but now," the poem turns, and the speaker begins to appear: "I feel," "I was," "I can give." The pronouns shift as the speaker reclaims attention for themselves. This is also where the poem takes stock. "I've given him my trust, love and loyalty" reads like a ledger, three valuable things listed in order, followed by the admission that "There's not much more I can give him." Giving here is a limited resource, and the speaker is running out of it.

The most revealing turn comes late. Until now the complaint has been neglect, but then the poem names "insults, lies and manipulation," which are not passive failings but actions. The speaker also introduces a judge: "The younger me would look and be disgusted with myself today." Here the hurt turns inward. The speaker is ashamed not only of how they were treated but of what they have put up with. The line is believable because it doesn't absolve anyone, including the speaker.

The last line has no full stop and no consoling resolution: "I don't know how long I can fight for a future that doesn't have a chance to survive." The future is treated almost like a living thing that can survive or fail, and the speaker, tired from fighting, is its only defender. The poem does not say whether they will leave, and the uncertainty feels honest.

What makes the poem worth reading is its candour and the way it gives shape to a feeling many readers will recognise. It doesn't rely on polish; it relies on precision, on the specific insult of the unsaved photograph and the cold accuracy of the recycling bin. It also shows how a pattern of mistreatment can be seen clearly once it is written down. Putting "insults, lies and manipulation" into a line is a way of refusing to pretend they are something milder.

Read also