Trees Falling — Summary

mlk911Contemplative

If a tree falls in a forest And no one's around to hear it Does it even make a sound? Of course it does What a stupid question Just because your ears Did not hear The tumble of the timber Doesn't mean it didn't happen. When we close our ears off to the world Things happen Whether we want it to Or not. If you really want to hear a tree Crash its last And first fall Open your ears And you'll hear The cry of the forest As it mourns a loss Of one of its own.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most people know the old puzzle about a tree falling in an empty forest, and this poem answers it bluntly: yes, of course it makes a sound. The speaker sounds impatient at first, calling the question "stupid," and the argument is simple. Just because you didn't hear something doesn't mean it didn't happen.

Then the poem widens out. Closing our ears to the world doesn't stop things from happening, whether we want them to or not. The tree becomes a way of talking about everything we choose not to notice.

The last lines shift the tone from irritation to tenderness. The speaker invites us to listen, and what we'd hear is "the cry of the forest" mourning one of its own. By treating the forest as a community that grieves, the poem turns a logic puzzle into a plea for attention and empathy. The mood moves from sharp and dismissive to quiet and sorrowful.

Read also

More by mlk911

All poems
Contemplativemlk911

Scars

I have a scar on my thumb Shaped like a crescent moon Well, maybe if the moon was drunk. I got it when I was twelve
Anxiousmlk911

What's Wrong With Me?

What is wrong with me? An unanswered question that refuses to become unstuck from the back of my mind A question with a seemingly endless possibility of answers But none are quite right.
Cheerfulmlk911

Stubbed Toes

Of all the horrors Stubbing your toes is the worst Death would be welcomed