Untitled 046 — Poem analysis

if it's love or not, but sometimes i imagine what 'us' would like 'us'--what a beautiful word! it can mean so much or so little it can be define or undefined

i wish i could ask how you feel and maybe i would make up my mind but maybe i wouldn't and sometimes i wonder if i just talk myself into believing there's more to this feeling

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The poem begins in the middle of a thought. "if it's love or not, but sometimes" is an "if" with no conclusion and a "but" that swerves before anything has been settled. We walk in on a private argument already underway. The speaker can't tell whether what they feel is love, daydreams about a couple they may not be, and suspects the daydream is homemade. The central idea is how easily longing builds a structure of meaning on very little, and how hard it is to tell that structure from the real thing when the other person hasn't spoken.

The word at the poem's centre is "us," and the speaker handles it carefully. The single quotation marks hold it up like an object in a display case, something to be admired rather than lived in. The one exclamation mark in the poem is spent on it: "what a beautiful word!" The delight is in the word, not in any relationship it names. The next lines let the air out: "it can mean so much or so little." The balance of that sentence is the speaker's whole predicament. A word that can mean anything has not yet been made to mean something. "it can be define or undefined" may be a slip for "defined," but the stumble suits a mind that keeps tripping over its own certainty. Earlier, "i imagine what 'us' would like" seems to be missing a word, probably "look." Judging by the text, the gap falls just where a picture of the couple should be, and the imagination supplies no details at all.

The second stanza moves from imagining to wishing. "i wish i could ask how you feel" is the only moment "you" appears, and the person it names stays blank throughout. The speaker never says why asking is impossible, only that it is, and the "could" leaves the question hanging. What follows is the poem's most honest turn. Most love poems treat the beloved's answer as the cure, but here the speaker admits it might not be: "maybe i would make up my mind / but maybe i wouldn't." Knowing how *you* feel might still not tell *me* what I feel.

The form carries this hesitation. Two five-line stanzas sit side by side like two attempts at the same thought. There is no regular metre or rhyme scheme, and most lines run to eight or nine syllables, close to the lilt of someone thinking aloud. The last line stretches to about eleven, as though the thought is spilling over. There are faint sound echoes, "undefined" with "mind" and "believing" with "feeling," but they never lock into a pattern. The final -ing chime closes the sound without closing the idea, and the poem ends with no full stop. Everything is in lowercase, even the pronoun "i," which gives the voice the smallness of a diary entry. "sometimes" appears in the first line and again in the seventh, so doubt comes back like a habit.

The vocabulary shrinks as the poem goes on. "love" appears once, in the opening line and under an "if." After that it is replaced by the vaguer "feeling" and "this," as if the speaker backs away from the largest word. The phrase "talk myself / into believing" is the most revealing in the poem. The speaker is the only voice in the room, and the poem is itself a kind of talking to oneself, which is the very habit it worries about.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it refuses both easy options. It won't announce a romance, and it won't dismiss one as foolish. It stays in the uncomfortable middle, where a feeling may be real or may be rehearsed, and the speaker is honest enough to say they can't tell. The title, "Untitled 046," suggests, as an inference, one piece in a longer run of unnamed pieces, and declining to title the poem echoes the speaker declining to name the feeling. For a young reader, the recognition is immediate. The poem catches how a crush can make a whole future out of a single word, and how a person can doubt that future while still wanting it.

Read also

More by P N C L S C R P T

All poems
RomanticP N C L S C R P T

Untitled 018

'Falling for you wasn't falling at all. It was like walking into a house and suddenly knowing I am home.'
DreamyP N C L S C R P T

Untitled 019

Those sleepless nights in my bed alone with a cup of brewed coffee While hugging my pillows and hiding under the cozy blanket Those countless hours ticking by That is when I had mastered the art of missing you~
SadP N C L S C R P T

Untitled 004

You don't love me. Even when you see me shedding in tears Your heart doesn't ache anymore. You don't love me.