Abby tells Liza — Poem analysis

Abby tells Liza they must leave. They pack and run. Rain drizzles. Below the freeway Abby and Liza wander.

Liza must pee. Abby tells Liza GO BEHIND A TREE. No trees. A man watches. PERVERT! Abby throws

a rock. Misses. Liza sneaks behind a dead Frigidaire. Abby tells Liza she may throw her own rocks. Liza throws rocks at men. Men protest

but leave her alone. Liza and Abby catch wisps of sleep on the street below the freeway. Nick seeks and finds them. He pleads

COME HOME WITH ME. Abby slings a rock at Nick. Stunned, he falls. Abby runs. Liza, torn, fusses

over Nick. He tells her CHASE ABBY. Liza cannot find her in the night grey. Later Liza goes home with Nick.

Abby is lost. The street smells like piss. Traffic, soft, steady, roars. Shifty characters trade places in the shadows.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Abby does the talking, and for most of the poem everyone else obeys. "Abby tells Liza they must leave" is how Pamela Hobart Carter begins, and the verb "tells" sets the pattern. The two women run from somewhere, shelter under a freeway, and are tracked down by a man named Nick. Liza ends up going "home with Nick," and Abby ends up "lost." The poem never says what they are running from, or whether Abby and Liza are friends, relatives or something else. What it does show is that escaping and being free are different things. Liza flees one set of instructions and walks back into another.

The capital letters carry that idea. Abby's order, "GO / BEHIND A TREE," is shouted on the page, and so are Nick's two commands, "COME HOME WITH ME" and "CHASE ABBY." Nick even borrows Abby's verb: "He tells her." Liza is told what to do by Abby, then by Nick, and the poem barely records a thought of her own. The one exception is brief and telling. Abby says Liza "may throw / her own rocks," and Liza does, at men who protest but "leave her alone." This is the poem's only moment of real autonomy, and it is granted by Abby, not claimed. When Nick arrives, Liza is "torn," and she "fusses" over the man her friend has just knocked down. The mild, almost domestic word "fusses" shows which pull is stronger.

The poem has no rhyme and no steady metre. Its energy comes from short, flat sentences stacked one after another: "Abby runs." "Misses." "Rain drizzles." The syntax is mostly subject and verb, like a list of events with no explanation. Against this, the line breaks keep cutting sentences open. "Abby throws" ends a line and the rock arrives in the next stanza. "Men" ends a line and "protest" sits alone at the start of the next, as limp as the men's objection. "He pleads" dangles at the end of a stanza, then Nick's capitalised plea lands by itself. The poem is mostly in three-line stanzas, with one stretched to four, and the sentences keep spilling over the gaps, which gives the reading a breathless, hurried feel that suits two people on the run.

The imagery is bare and hard. Rocks are the poem's only tools, and the violence in it passes along a chain. Abby throws first and "Misses." Liza learns to throw too. Then Abby's rock hits Nick, the one person who comes with a plea, not a threat. The "dead Frigidaire" is the sharpest object in the poem. A fridge is a symbol of home, and here it is a dumped corpse that offers Liza a little privacy. It shows how close to nothing the women have, and it sits ironically beside the "home" Liza later chooses. The freeway presses down on everything. The women sleep "below the freeway" and wander "below" it, and the repeated word keeps them under the weight of the city.

The final stanza drops Liza and Nick, and the sense of smell takes over: "The street smells / like piss." Then comes the odd phrase "Traffic, soft, steady, roars." Three words suggest calm and the verb contradicts them, so the noise is both background hum and constant threat. The last line, "Shifty characters trade places in the shadows," turns people into anonymous types. Judging by how the poem shifts here, Abby has become one of them, no longer a character who gives orders but another figure in the dark. The woman who commanded the first line is the one left with no one to command.

That quiet reversal is what makes the poem worth reading. In just over twenty lines it tells a story that most writers would need pages for, and it refuses to explain or judge. Readers must decide for themselves whether Liza has been rescued or recaptured, and whether Abby's bossiness was protection or control. The poem leaves both readings open, and the flat, plain voice makes the open question hit harder.

Read also

More by Pamela Hobart Carter

All poems
ContemplativePamela Hobart Carter

Lines of Sight are Reversible

Expect when facing mirrors glimpses at infinities, sureness of self, in this breathing state, instead, discover bowed lattices shuttering future or past or whatever
DreamyPamela Hobart Carter

Fried Egg on the Plate, Without the Plate

None of it makes sense or it all does, doesn’t matter, what matters is how we recognize Dali’s dangling egg, the yolk-sunny sky, and the odd shelf
CheerfulPamela Hobart Carter

Apology

I apologize for finding this dog to shadow you even as you pace the attic from desk to window, you and he, a pair now, contemplating those tough computer programming issues