You Don’t Have to Answer — Summary

What if every drop of rain needs the patch

of sidewalk where it lands? Every sky

needs cumulous to fill it? I need the umbrella

that needs the raindrops to shape the wet arch

overhead. We are all here because I put

us here. I need here and us

and this poem to put things in.

What does the poem need? Or do you

need the poem? The umbrella knows you need the poems.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Pamela Hobart Carter starts with a playful question: what if each raindrop needs the exact patch of sidewalk where it falls? From there the poem builds a chain of dependence. Skies need clouds, the speaker needs an umbrella, and the umbrella needs raindrops to give it a purpose and a shape. Nothing here stands alone.

Then the speaker turns to the poem itself. By saying "We are all here because I put us here," the speaker admits to being the one who made this little world, and needs it as a place "to put things in." The ending turns toward the reader with a gentle question: does the poem need you, or do you need it? The umbrella, oddly, "knows" the answer.

The mood is light, curious and warm. It feels like a quiet thought spoken aloud, and it suggests that poems, like umbrellas, shelter us a little.

Read also

More by Pamela Hobart Carter

All poems
ContemplativePamela Hobart Carter

Lineal

Visualize a picture of an apple, one side green, other, red Connect by lines—how else? Look at a lecturer who gestures lineal
ContemplativePamela Hobart Carter

Yearning

I do not want to be remembered for my urine. In this I differ from the chowchow and Welsh corgi
AnxiousPamela Hobart Carter

Monochrome

Branches overhang stairs which lead to a grassy place, a stump washed in sun.