technology can be dumb — Poem analysis

computers i love 'em computers i hate 'em computers computers computers i like my phone i dispise my phone stupid stupid phone i need a lawn mower i don't need a lawn mower oww my toes are gone rolling rolling rolling rolling rolling smack good bye wheelchair hello pavement beep stare beep i have a headache glug silence ... glug silence ... OH MY GOD i have an IV beep dammit beep dumb pacemaker beep think beep think beep think i unplug it beep beep ... ... ...beep i can't think i cant think i can't think ice cream ice cream ice cream

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Within the first few lines of Quinn Heathrow's «technology can be dumb», the speaker has contradicted themselves, and that habit drives everything that follows. "computers i love 'em / computers i hate 'em." "i like my phone / i dispise my phone." "i need a lawn mower / i don't need a lawn mower." Each pair cancels itself out, so the opening sounds like someone talking in circles, with the grumbling tone of a person scrolling through a day. The stakes feel tiny, and "stupid stupid phone" is a complaint almost anyone could make.

Then the poem swerves. "oww my toes are gone" follows straight after the lawn-mower lines, so the poem suggests, without ever saying so, that the machine the speaker couldn't decide about has done its damage. The next lines run on speed: "rolling rolling rolling / rolling rolling smack." The repeated word picks up momentum like a wheelchair on a slope, and "smack" stops it dead. "good bye wheelchair hello pavement" is a joke made at the speed of a fall. Even the device meant to help the speaker has become one more machine that fails.

From here the poem turns into sound effects. "beep stare beep." "glug silence ..." Ordinary sentences shrink while the machines grow louder, and the speaker's language seems to wear away as their situation worsens. The only capital letters in the poem arrive in "OH MY GOD i have an IV", a comic and frightened moment of noticing, like someone realising they have been plugged in the whole time.

The title's word comes back at the centre: "dumb pacemaker." It works in two ways. The device is stupid, and it is also mute, able only to say "beep." The speaker tries to argue with it, and the lines shuffle two words against each other: "beep think beep / think beep think." By the end of that run, "think" has crowded out "beep", as though the speaker is trying to out-think a heartbeat. Then comes the plainest line in the poem: "i unplug it." Nothing is shouted, and there is no explanation. A real pacemaker sits inside the body and cannot simply be unplugged, so the poem seems to be working by nightmare logic rather than realism. The beeps thin out afterwards ("beep beep ... / ... ...beep"), and the ellipses act as silence you can see on the page.

The ending is the cleverest part. "i can't think" appears three times, and the middle version loses its apostrophe: "i cant think." Judging by the text, punctuation is the first thing to go, a small slip that acts out the failing mind. Then the poem settles into "ice cream / ice cream / ice cream." Several readings are possible. It might be a dying mind grabbing at comfort, a retreat into childlike wanting, or a hallucination. The poem refuses to choose. It does, though, echo the opening, where "computers computers computers" is answered by a closing triple. The poem runs like a program that freezes and repeats its last instruction. What replaces the computers is something sweet, cold and simple, and not plugged into anything.

Formally, the poem has no rhyme, no punctuation to speak of, and lines of a few words each. Its rhythm comes from repetition and from sound words like "glug", "smack" and "beep". The lowercase and the casual misspelling of "dispise" make it read like speech, or like something typed in a hurry. That casualness is what makes the darkness land. Nothing in the poem stops to lecture, and the comedy keeps pulling the reader along until the jokes stop working.

The poem matters because it takes the title's complaint further than it first seems to go. Calling technology "dumb" sounds like blame, but the poem shows machines doing exactly what they were built to do without any understanding, and that is the danger. The human half of the stupidity is in the poem too. This is a speaker who can't decide whether they need the mower, and who in the final crisis pulls the plug. The poem never says who is dumber, the machine or the person, and the ice cream at the end makes that question impossible to answer.

Read also

More by Quinn Heathrow

All poems
CheerfulQuinn Heathrow

Before Tomorrow

Before tomorrow I will get ou of bed, brush my teeth, and trudge like led. Before tomorrow I will walk down the street,
AnxiousQuinn Heathrow

Nightmares

Panic right when you wake up not sure if you are still asleep.
DreamyQuinn Heathrow

Waiting For the Day

I silently sit by the window staring deep into the night sky. Hoping for something to crash down from the heavens,