Bruised Inside & Out — Poem analysis

She'd wake the next morning hoping it was just a dream finding out her mommy really wasn't mean

A bat or a broomstick A hnager or a hand A little or a lot She couldn't understand

Why someone who claimed to care would shout and yell and pull her hair

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most poems about violence reach for big, dramatic words. "Bruised Inside & Out" does the reverse. It is built from the plainest vocabulary, the kind a child might use, and that restraint makes it hard to shake. It is about a girl hurt by the person who is supposed to protect her. Its central idea is the confusion that follows: not only the pain, but the impossibility of fitting that pain together with the word "mommy."

The title does work the poem never does. The twelve lines contain no word like "bruise" or "hit," and the ampersand in the title promises damage in two places, the body and something less visible. The poem then spends its time on the inside kind, the bewilderment.

The first stanza is the most puzzling and the most revealing. The girl wakes "hoping it was just a dream," which suggests that whatever happened the day before was too frightening to be real. Then comes the odd phrasing "finding out her mommy / really wasn't mean." One reading is that the morning brings an ordinary, calm mother, and the girl is relieved, or persuaded, that the cruelty was imagined. Another is that this is the child's wish, stated as if it were fact. Either way, the poem suggests a child who would rather doubt her own memory than doubt her mother. The word "really" sounds like someone insisting, trying to convince herself.

The second stanza turns to what actually happens, and it does so as a list: "A bat or a broomstick / A hnager or a hand." I take "hnager" to be a slip for "hanger," judging by the pattern of household objects. These are things found in any home, and the list ends on the bare hand, the most intimate of them. The repeated "a … or a" structure makes the catalogue sound casual, almost routine, as though the object hardly matters. The next line uses the same grammar for something else: "A little or a lot." Now the variable is severity, and this is the line that explains the girl's bewilderment. If the punishment sometimes comes small and sometimes large, there is no rule to learn and nothing to predict. "She couldn't understand" is therefore less a statement of innocence than an accurate report.

The sentence then spills across the stanza break, "She couldn't understand / Why someone who / claimed to care," and the enjambment lets the question run on the way a child's "why" does. The sharpest word in the poem is "claimed." Almost everything else is simple and childlike, but "claimed" carries doubt about whether the care was ever real. It may be the voice of an older, more knowing speaker stepping in over the child's shoulder. After it the verbs shrink and double up: "shout and yell," "pull her hair." The near-synonyms pile up noise, and the final image is small and domestic, a handful of hair, after the bat and the broomstick. The poem stops there, with no punctuation at all and no answer to the "why." The ending is a question the girl cannot close.

The sound of the poem works against its subject. The lines are short, mostly four to six syllables, and the second and fourth lines of each stanza rhyme: dream/mean, hand/understand, care/hair. That gives the poem the bounce of a nursery rhyme, a form associated with comfort. Setting such a jingle against a bat and a pulled head of hair is unsettling. The first pair, "dream" and "mean," is the loosest, matching only in its vowel sound. That fits the stanza in which the girl's grip on what is true is also loosest, though that is a reading rather than a certainty.

What makes the poem significant is its refusal to explain or decorate. It does not name the mother as an abuser, offer a moral, or promise rescue. It stays at the child's height and records what she sees and feels. In doing so it captures something that larger language can miss, that the worst part of being hurt by someone you love may be not knowing how to think about them afterward.

Read also

More by Raven Alexis

All poems
SadRaven Alexis

The Sadness

Thinking of you I lean over silent water, this head appears. The earth turns, the sky has no motion.
SadRaven Alexis

DADDY WHY?

I remember when i was the twinkle in my daddy's eyes. Then he left one day without saying good-bye.