Until — Poem analysis

I love enough until it turns cold I hate enough until the fire burn bold I care enough till the trust is gone I feel sorry until I see it's wrong I'm gone, hidden in the shade ( you can't see me ) I'm gone, until you forget my name ( i hope ) then I'm gone ( hidden in a song ) then I'm gone ( I'll be hiding behind the song ) I care, till the well runs dry I cried, until my eye's ran dry I held on, till my grip was gone I called your name, till i was deaf and dumb Now I'm just gone, hidden in the shade ( you can't see me ) I'm gone, until I forget your name ( i hope ) then I'll be gone ( hidden in a song ) then I'll just be gone ( I'll be hiding behind the song ) I loved, till it turned to hate I fumed, till I lost the flames I shouted, till I had no voice I left, when I had no choice I was gone, hidden in the the shade ( you can't see me ) I'm gone, till I forget your name ( i hope ) then I'll be gone ( hidden in a song ) then I'll just be gone ( I'll be hiding behind the song ) just to see you cry I'm not even sure why maybe I'll see the pain that you saw in me every day then I'll just hide, in the shade ( you can't see me ) I'll be gone, till I forget your name ( i hope ) then I'll be gone ( hidden in a song ) then I'll just be gone ( I'll be hiding behind the song ) Is that what you had for me unending pain and misery I tell myself I'll heal but there is no memory repeal I'll just hide in the shade ( you can't see me ) I'll eventually forget your name ( i hope ) Then I'll just be gone ( hidden in a song ) then I'll be glad I'm gone ( I'll be hiding behind the song )

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Every line of "Until" comes with an expiry date. Love lasts only "until it turns cold," care only "till the trust is gone," and the speaker is left emptied out by a relationship that gave back pain. The poem's central idea is that leaving is rarely one decisive act. It is a slow draining of feeling, and the wish to vanish is both a defence and a quiet kind of wound.

The poem is built on repetition. The opening lines set each emotion against a limit: love, hate, care and pity all run on a timer. Fire and cold appear straight away ("until the fire burn bold"), and the imagery then shifts from weather to the body. A well runs dry, then eyes run dry, then a grip is "gone," then a voice, then hearing: "I called your name, till i was deaf and dumb." The speaker is spent in a very physical way, and the repeated "till" makes the exhaustion feel like something counted out line by line. One line breaks the pattern: "I left, when I had no choice." It is the only place where "when" replaces "until," and the small swap carries the point. Everything else wore away over time, but leaving was forced.

Between these verses the refrain keeps returning, and it is where the poem is most inventive. "Hidden in the shade" is a clever image after all that fire, because shade is relief and also concealment. The parentheses work like whispered asides: "(you can't see me)," "(i hope)." The speaker states a plan and then undercuts it with doubt. The refrain also shifts as the poem goes on. At first the speaker will be gone "until you forget my name," but by the second round it is "until I forget your name." The wish to be forgotten turns into the harder task of forgetting, and that is where the real struggle lies. By the last stanza even the certainty has softened to "I'll eventually forget your name."

Rhyme and rhythm keep the poem close to speech, or to song lyrics. Most lines fall into rough couplets, and many of the rhymes are loose: "gone" with "wrong," "gone" with "dumb," "pain" with "day." Some are exact and bitter, such as "cry" and "why," or "voice" and "choice." "Dry" rhymes with itself across two lines, as if the speaker has run out of new words as well as tears. The lines are short and heavily stressed, so they land like blunt statements. The grammar is unpolished in places ("the fire burn bold," "the the shade"), which keeps the voice raw and unedited. Whether or not that was intended, it suits a poem about feelings that haven't been tidied up.

The later stanzas are the most revealing. "Just to see you cry / I'm not even sure why" admits an ugly impulse, and the speaker doesn't pretend to understand it. Then comes the hope of seeing "the pain / that you saw in me every day," which suggests the other person watched the suffering and did nothing. The question "Is that what you had for me / unending pain and misery" has no answer. "There is no memory repeal" borrows the language of law, as if memory were a rule that can't be cancelled. That undermines the promise to forget, and "I tell myself I'll heal" sounds like self-persuasion rather than fact.

The ending is the poem's quietest turn. "Gone" has meant leaving, vanishing and being drained, but in the last line the speaker is "glad I'm gone." It is a small and uncertain victory, since the speaker is still "hiding behind the song." Judging by the text, the song may be the poem itself, a place to put pain so it can be survived without being faced head-on.

That is what gives "Until" its value as a poem to study. It shows how form can carry emotion: a single repeated word measures how much was lost, and a changing refrain tracks a change of heart. It doesn't offer a neat recovery. It lets the speaker stay in the in-between place, where healing is something to be hoped for rather than announced.

Read also

More by Rich Mansfield

All poems
ContemplativeRich Mansfield

Hate Armor

The anger it screamed with a never ending hiss, scalding the skin of my heart with a boiling kiss, the pain sinking deeper into the tissue to find it's own home within and without my mind, alone,
SadRich Mansfield

Anymore

Cast a baleful look my way just another day here in this life can't be the excited person you wish i use to be that's just not me
SadRich Mansfield

Useless smiles

I smile for the world I smile for you, I smile for me but this smile isn't me it isn't me