A Monk on the Street — Poem analysis

Ruth JewellInspired

The line forms here men, women, old and young wait

forgotten all except by The Monk on the Street

A bowl of soup a handshake, contact …

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nine short lines are enough for Ruth Jewell to build a whole scene: a queue, a crowd nobody is thinking about, and one figure who is. "A Monk on the Street" is about what it means to be noticed. The people in the line are presumably hungry, since a bowl of soup is mentioned, but the poem cares more about a second hunger, the need to be treated as someone rather than something. Its central idea is that a small, physical act of kindness can give back a dignity the rest of the world has taken away.

The first stanza is as plain as a sign on a door. "The line forms here" is in the present tense, and the word "here" points like a finger. We are not told what the line is for, and we have to work that out later. The second line, "men, women, old and young", is a list that tries to cover everybody. It also gives us nobody in particular: no names, no faces, only categories. Then comes "wait", alone on its own line. The long subject has been hanging without its verb, and when the verb finally arrives it is a single beat, followed by white space. The reader is made to wait too, so the form does what the word says.

The second stanza turns on a pivot. "Forgotten all" has an inverted word order that sounds quiet and final, like a verdict, and "all" leaves no one out. Then the line break after "except by" holds us on a preposition, in suspense, before the exception arrives: "The Monk on the Street." Every word is capitalised, as if it were a title or a proper name, and the capitals give him weight without describing him. We learn nothing about his face, his age or his beliefs. All we get is where he is. "On the street" suggests, as an inference, a figure whose calling has moved out of any enclosed building and into the open, among the people who are waiting.

The last stanza is the most interesting, because it has no verbs at all. "A bowl of soup / a handshake, / contact …" is a list of nouns, and the monk never grammatically *does* anything. The kindness appears as plain fact, with no sermon and no praise attached. The list also moves upward. Soup feeds the body, a handshake is a gesture between equals rather than from giver to receiver, and "contact" is what remains when the occasion is stripped away. It is a slightly clinical word, closer to wires and emergency signals than to comfort, and that makes it surprising here. In this setting it becomes warm. The ellipsis that follows leaves the word hanging, which could mean the contact goes on past the handshake, or that the poet has no better name for it.

The poem has no rhyme and no regular metre. It is free verse in three even tercets, and its rhythm comes from short lines and from pauses that fall at line endings rather than at punctuation. The only marks are a few commas and that final ellipsis. The structure is a miniature of the poem's argument. The first stanza shows the crowd, the second turns toward the one person who sees them, and the third gives what he offers. The equal stanzas might even feel like equal portions, though that is a reading rather than a certainty.

The poem is significant because of its restraint. It could have described suffering in detail or praised the monk at length, and it does neither. It uses only the bare minimum of words, and in doing so it practises the attention it describes. The people in the queue are "forgotten all", yet for nine lines a poem is looking at them. A reader finishes it asking a quiet, uncomfortable question about the lines they walk past every day and who, if anyone, is noticing the people standing in them.

Read also

More by Ruth Jewell

All poems
SadRuth Jewell

WATCH DOG

Come in old friend It’s time to rest you feet And let the ghosts pass by Come in and rest your weary body
DreamyRuth Jewell

The Eagle

Walking the rocky shore Cold wind from the Baltic Sea washes over me On a rocky outcrop she sits Mysterious black, white crowned head