Looks Like Faith — Poem analysis

Chill southern winds shove and pummel grand leafing maples, stately cedars and firs, day after day from one month into another, cracking off thick limbs, hurling them to sodden ground impaled by deadwood spears, strewn with ragged branches,

some tipped abundantly with leaf buds as firm and flush as magnolia, fat with futile purpose. Dwarfed fruit trees—an apple, a pear— without choice, raise translucent petals, sturdy as moth’s wings, to this fierceness.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The word "faith" never appears inside Samanthe Sheffer's poem. The title makes a claim, "looks like," and the ten lines that follow supply only the evidence: wind, broken wood, buds, and a few blossoms. The reader has to work out why this scene counts as faith. The answer the poem seems to give is that faith is not calm or strong. It is fragile things held up to a force that could destroy them.

The first sentence is built to feel endless. It runs from "Chill southern winds" through seven lines and across the stanza break, piling up verbs as it goes: "shove and pummel," "cracking off," "hurling," "impaled," "strewn." The line endings help the wind's work. "Day after / day" is split in two, so the days literally drag across a line break, and "grand / leafing maples" leaves the word "grand" hanging just before the trees are cut down to size. The imagery turns the storm into a battlefield. Fallen limbs are "deadwood spears," so the trees seem to be impaled on their own dead parts. The grand trees, the "stately cedars and firs," get the most dignified adjectives and take the worst damage.

Then, in the middle of that wreckage, come the buds. Some of the broken branches are "tipped abundantly with leaf buds as firm / and flush as magnolia." The simile borrows the look of a tree that flowers boldly, and the sound softens too: "firm and flush," "fat with futile." After all the hard consonants of the storm, the f-sounds feel almost plump. But the phrase "fat with futile purpose" holds the poem's central tension. The buds are full of purpose, yet the speaker calls it futile, because the branch carrying them is already on the ground. Judging by this phrasing, the poem does not pretend that hope is always rewarded. It allows that some of it is wasted.

The second sentence is much shorter, and its rhythm changes. The subject, "Dwarfed fruit trees," arrives after the grand trees have been dismantled, and the dash adds a quiet, specific aside: "an apple, a pear." After the generic list of maples, cedars and firs, two named fruit trees feel almost tender. The main verb, "raise," is held back by the phrase "without choice." That phrase can be read two ways. The trees are rooted and cannot flee the wind, but they also cannot choose not to blossom. If so, the poem suggests faith is closer to instinct or necessity than to a decision, something the trees do because they are what they are.

The petals are "translucent," so light passes through them, and they are compared to a moth's wings. Both details stress how little protection they have. Yet the comparison ends on "sturdy," a surprising word to attach to such delicate things. The poem finishes on "this fierceness," with no verdict on whether the blossoms survive. The last action is a lifting-up, and the poem stops there. That choice keeps the poem honest: it shows the gesture, not the outcome.

There is no rhyme here and no regular meter. The long, heavy lines and the unbroken sentence suit a wind that does not let up, and the shorter closing sentence suits the small, deliberate act of the blossoms. The title also asks us to notice who is doing the looking. "Looks like" admits that the trees do not know they are showing faith; a human eye is reading it into them.

That is the poem's real achievement. It does not preach about belief. It puts faith in a place where it costs something, among splintered limbs and a long run of bad weather, and lets the reader decide whether lifting a petal into a gale is foolish or brave.

Read also