Eating Silence — Poem analysis

Open up your ears Hungry for the soothing sound Swallow the silence Cut the tasty music notes Eat lunch with a violin

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Five short lines, and almost every one is an instruction. Thomas W. Morris's "Eating Silence" never says "I" and never describes a scene. It simply gives orders: open, swallow, cut, eat. The reader is treated less like an audience than like a guest at a table, and the meal is made of sound.

The central idea is a blurring of the senses. Hearing is rewritten as eating, so ears become mouths ("Open up your ears") and listening becomes appetite ("Hungry for the soothing sound"). The poem suggests that attention is a kind of hunger, and that quiet and music are things we need rather than decorations. The oddest moment comes in the third line, "Swallow the silence." Silence is the absence of sound, and the poem asks us to take it in as if it had substance. The paradox works because it matches a real experience: a pause in a piece of music, or a quiet room after noise, can feel full rather than empty. Judging by the imagery, the poem asks us to treat silence as something to be taken in rather than merely endured.

The construction is spare. There is no rhyme, but the lines have a pattern. Counting syllables, they run five, seven, five, seven, seven. That alternation gives the poem a quiet, balanced pulse, with the short lines like small intakes of breath and the longer ones like the swallow that follows. Nothing in the text says this was planned, but the effect is of something carefully trimmed, with no wasted words.

The sound of the words does a great deal of the work. The hushing s sounds in "soothing sound," "swallow the silence" make the lines themselves feel soft and low, almost like a whisper. Then the fourth line changes texture: "Cut the tasty music notes." The hard t sounds in "cut," "tasty" and "notes" are crisp and clipped, like a knife meeting a board. The line makes us hear the action it describes. The word "cut" is also interesting in itself. Music notes are normally things we hear in a flowing stream, but here they are portioned out like slices of bread. One reading is that music is carved out of silence, so that the notes are what remains when a piece is cut from the quiet around it. That is an interpretation, but the order of the lines supports it: silence is swallowed first, and the notes arrive only afterwards.

"Tasty" is the most playful word in the poem. It is plain, even childlike, and it pulls an abstract idea back to everyday pleasure. The poem does not talk of "exquisite" or "sublime" music. It uses the vocabulary of a school canteen, and that keeps it from sounding pretentious.

The final line is the most surprising: "Eat lunch with a violin." After the strange, almost mystical instructions, the poem lands on something ordinary, a midday meal. The violin is not on a stage or in a concert hall. It sits across the table like a companion. The humour is gentle, but there is also an argument here, which is that art does not have to be saved for special occasions. It can be part of routine, as normal as lunch. The line is the longest in the poem, and it ends on the soft, flowing sounds of "lunch with a violin," so the poem finishes on warmth rather than on an abstraction.

The poem is significant for how much it does in so little space. In five lines it makes a synaesthetic metaphor, a paradox, a shift in sound and a change of tone from the dreamlike to the domestic. It also gives readers something to do. After reading it, it is hard not to notice the quiet in a room, or to listen a little more hungrily to the next piece of music. For students, it is a good example of how a poem can build its meaning from one extended image, here eating, and carry it through every line without ever explaining itself.

Read also

More by Thomas W. Morris

All poems
AngryThomas W. Morris

The tip of the arrow

The tip of the arrow, the sharpest point of the weapon, the most feared by its foe. The tip of the arrow,
SadThomas W. Morris

I walk these cold streets

I walk these cold streets, through the fuses of light, they glow on the concrete, and kindle the night.
ContemplativeThomas W. Morris

Fishing

One morning I went fishing The sun sparkled against the waves Why Why did I go fishing