«she stared at him…» — Poem analysis

Tim GunnContemplative

she stared at him as if there was nothing else to look at when they had been together a month or so he finally wanted to know more about her he did not know how to touch her or even how to desire such expertise immense sadness engulfed her the silent expanse between words and whispers

she found another rife with lustrous gestures could pretend that there was love in his eyes last chance to be observed measured desired before her contents were judged by their cover must open now delicate flower the bitter taste of her progress was slow their hands prancing like puppeteers her body as canonized sculpture his lips trembling she left him against the wall saturated in exultation

another agreed to marry because he had no more use for her she had different eyes then the full consonance of eventide no warmth of daylight could any longer rouse her heart but one day and another and watching while life goes by years later she would hardly remember his face he had asked who she would be without him so he became a paintstruck clown in her rare dreams when he died earlier than expected she learned to worship

her son escaped her elapsed endearment he had found a beautiful vessel to convey his luggage she was now the mother over whom a wife had to prevail there was the occasional call she could not accept nor could she endorse her spellbound grandchildren crawling about to the beat of some uncanny anapest better to be unobtrusive and learn to die alone her heart was a diamond waiting to be excavated she released her love to one who asked hard questions he had mastered a way to argue that made her cackle he took photographs and lingered over the wrinkles love could be careless and she was glad to listen with her mouth they had hoarded enough allegory to recite over coffee and toast each had survived an entire life with souls stored elsewhere their hearts encumbered with yearnings but having lingered now no longer waiting to be reunited

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four partners, a son, a scatter of grandchildren, and a woman who never gets a name. The poem has no title beyond a row of asterisks, and it runs through a whole life in thirty-nine lines by asking one question: who actually sees her?

The first stanza begins with her attention. She "stared at him as if there was nothing else to look at," but it takes him a month to want "to know more about her," and even then he "did not know how to touch her." The sadness that follows is a place, "the silent expanse between words and whispers." The second stanza shows her settling for a performance. Her new lover is "rife with lustrous gestures" and "could pretend that there was love in his eyes," and she accepts, because this is her "last chance to be observed measured desired / before her contents were judged by their cover." The old proverb is turned around. She fears that once her surface ages, nobody will read the rest. The touching is staged, with hands "prancing like puppeteers" and her body "as canonized sculpture," honoured and motionless. When she leaves him, he is "saturated in exultation," so the triumph was his all along.

Marriage is bleaker still. The line "another agreed to marry because he had no more use for her" is ambiguous, but its coldness is clear, since it makes marriage sound like a transaction. Her eyes change to "the full consonance of eventide," and nothing in "daylight" can "rouse her heart." The years pass in a single unpunctuated slide: "but one day and another and watching while life goes by." Her husband asks "who she would be without him," which sounds like a question but works as a claim of ownership. He shrinks into "a paintstruck clown in her rare dreams." When he dies she "learned to worship," and the poem never says what. Judging by the surrounding lines, it could be her own freedom or life itself, and the missing object leaves the reader to decide.

The final stanza nearly doubles in length (fifteen lines against eight), as if the poem finally slows down for the part that matters. First comes loss. Her son "escaped her elapsed endearment" and she becomes "the mother over whom a wife had to prevail." Her grandchildren crawl "to the beat of some uncanny anapest," the one place the poem names a regular rhythm, and it belongs to a family she is shut out of. The poem itself keeps no such beat. It has no rhyme, no capitals and no punctuation. Nearly every line is a plain clause starting with "she" or "he," like entries in a ledger, and the lines pour into one another so that the reader supplies the pauses.

Then the diction loosens. Her heart is "a diamond waiting to be excavated," a stock image, but "excavated" suggests slow digging, and the last man does it with "hard questions," unlike the husband's possessive one. He "took photographs and lingered over the wrinkles," which answers the fear of the second stanza, because the cover is read and loved. Their talk is bodily and funny: she can "cackle," and she is "glad to listen with her mouth." Even their shared stories are mixed with breakfast, as they "hoarded enough allegory to recite over coffee and toast," so a grand literary word sits beside toast.

The vocabulary is bookish throughout, with "canonized," "consonance," "anapest" and "allegory." The poem describes her life in the language of reading, which suits its theme of being read well or badly. Its last lines return to two earlier words. Their hearts are "encumbered with yearnings but having lingered / now no longer waiting to be reunited." The poem never says who is to be reunited with whom, perhaps with the "souls stored elsewhere" or with earlier selves, and I read the ending as relief that the waiting is over. Its significance lies in how it treats love as attention rather than display or ownership, and in how it lets a woman's late life end in company, laughter and being looked at properly.

Read also

More by Tim Gunn

All poems
SadTim Gunn

* * *

he fixed on her pensive glistering eyes but would utter naught he wondered at
ContemplativeTim Gunn

* * *

she left his skin on fire words tumbled out in a skeletal gasping wish now won’t you have a little
SadTim Gunn

* * *

evenly and ivory in her raw recollection she reasoned helplessly at least one of us is wrong