Do You Ever Think About Her... — Poem analysis

Do you ever think about her, The girl who helps you out? The one who tells you the answers And leaves without a doubt.

Do you ever think about her, As she sits next to you in class, Jotting down her notes, That you'll take with so much brass.

Do you think about the girl, Who you shout at in the street, When all she's doing is going home, shuffling her feet?

Do you think about the girl, Who's parents think she's shit, Because she got a ninety, Something they wouldn't permit?

Do you think about the girl, as she studies so hard a night, she can't sleep all alone, because you gave her a fright?

Do you think about the girl, who struggles through her life, trying to seem so normal, though wants to take a knife?

Do you think about the girl, who just wants to be like you? 'Cos you should know she thinks of you.

She thinks of what you call her, She hopes to be that good, She smiles and laughs, Though she cries behind the hood.

So call her a nerd, A geek, A boff, But please, Don't ever, Ever, Call her a genius. That's the one thing she knows she can't be.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The name attached to this piece is Vampire Gal, and the page gives us nothing else to go on, so everything here comes from the words themselves. What they offer is a long, accusing question addressed to a classmate: do you ever think about the girl you use and mock? The central idea is an imbalance of attention. The "you" of the poem barely notices her, yet she is preoccupied with him or her, as the seventh stanza admits: "she thinks of you."

The poem's structure is a slow retreat from public to private. It begins in the classroom, with a girl who "tells you the answers" and whose notes are taken "with so much brass" (slang for cheek or nerve). It moves to the street, where she is shouted at on her way home, then to her parents' house, then to her sleepless night, and finally to her inner life. Each stanza starts with nearly the same question, and the repetition works like a prosecutor's cross-examination. The wording hardens as it goes. The early "Do you ever think about her" is almost polite, while the later "Do you think about the girl" is blunter and more insistent.

The rhyme is loose, mostly the second and fourth lines of each stanza chiming: out/doubt, class/brass, street/feet. The rhythm is short and conversational, closer to speech than to formal verse, and it sometimes stumbles, as in the "Who's parents" of stanza four. That rawness suits a poem that wants to sound like something said directly to someone's face. Some of the rhymes carry real weight. "Life" is paired with "knife," so that the ordinary and the lethal sit side by side in one neat sound. Because the rhyme is so tidy, the dark thought feels all the more flat and casual. The identical rhyme of "you" with "you" in stanza seven makes the same point in another way. She is stuck on this person and can't find a different word to land on.

The imagery is small and physical. "Shuffling her feet" shows someone trying to take up less space. The "hood" she cries behind is both clothing and shelter, and it sets her outward behaviour, "She smiles and laughs," against what happens beneath it. The phrase "trying to seem so normal" suggests that her ordinary appearance is a performance she must keep up. The line "wants to take a knife" is the darkest in the poem, and it is delivered without melodrama. That plainness makes it more unsettling, because it presents the moment as one more fact about her day. The poem also gives her a double bind at home: a ninety is something her parents "wouldn't permit," so success is treated as a failure. Nowhere in her life does achievement bring her comfort.

The ending is where the poem becomes most inventive. The last stanza breaks into single-word lines, "A nerd, / A geek, / A boff," as if the insults are being thrown one after another. Then the speaker pleads: "But please, / Don't ever, / Ever, / Call her a genius." The stammering repetition of "ever" sounds like someone running out of breath. The final line then runs long and flat: "That's the one thing she knows she can't be." The poem doesn't explain why, so any reading is an inference. One possibility is that "genius" implies effortless talent, which would erase the sleepless hours the poem shows. Another is that it would raise a standard she already feels she is failing. Either way, the insults can be survived, but the compliment would be unbearable because she doesn't believe it.

The intimacy of the poem's knowledge, including her thoughts, her hopes and her tears, makes it plausible that the speaker is the girl herself, though the text never says so. What makes the poem significant is how it turns a familiar school scene around. Studious pupils are usually seen from outside, as figures of fun or envy, and here we are made to see inside. The poem also refuses an easy resolution, with no rescue and no revenge, only a request that the reader pay attention. It leaves us with an uncomfortable idea: even praise can hurt when someone has been taught to doubt herself.

Read also

More by Vampire Gal

All poems
ContemplativeVampire Gal

if's and why's

if love is a state of mind, why does it hurt your heart? if fear is just adrenaline, why do we sense trouble
CheerfulVampire Gal

Options

Smile and the whole world thinks your weird Scowl and you'll fit right in
AngryVampire Gal

Because You Did

To all those who like to hurt Those who just want to stay standing up I give to you the product of your ways I give you all that you caused