«Someone once told me that…» — Poem analysis

victorContemplative

Someone once told me that none of us are actually afraid of the dark; we're scared of what it conceals from us. We're afraid of having something with the potential to hurt us standing right before eyes and not registering it as a threat people can be like that, too.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Hardly anyone would call a poem about the dark a confession, but "* * *" reads like one. The poem is signed only "victor" and has no title beyond the asterisks that conventionally stand in for one. It begins with a borrowed thought: "Someone once told me that none of us are actually afraid of the dark." The speaker passes on a piece of wisdom from an unnamed person, then adds a final line that turns it from a remark about night into a remark about human beings.

The borrowed idea is that fear of the dark is a misreading of ourselves. We aren't frightened of blackness, only of "what it conceals / from us." The sentence that follows is the most interesting one, because it quietly changes the picture. What we dread is "having something with the / potential to hurt us standing / right before eyes and / not registering it as a / threat." Look at the logic. A threat standing "right before eyes" is in plain view, which is the opposite of darkness. The fear has stopped being about missing light and become a fear of missing meaning: the danger is there, visible, and we simply fail to read it. The word "potential" matters too. The thing that frightens us hasn't hurt anyone yet, and that is exactly why it can go unnoticed.

The last line, "people can be like that, too," lands the point. The dark becomes a way of describing people, who can hide what they are while standing in full view. The phrase is also pleasantly ambiguous. A person might be like the dark, concealing something harmful behind an ordinary surface. Or people might be like the frightened observer, looking straight at danger and not seeing it. The poem doesn't choose, and both readings are uncomfortable. The first makes us wary of others, and the second makes us wary of ourselves.

The construction supports this. There is no rhyme and no steady meter. The lines are short and ragged, mostly four to six syllables, and the line breaks keep stopping on small, weak words. "We're" ends one line, "the" ends another, "a" ends a third. Each break makes the reader hover for a moment before the sentence continues, much like feeling for a light switch. The effect suits a poem about incomplete perception, because we never see a whole thought at once, only the piece the line gives us.

The most striking break comes at "threat," which sits alone on its line with no punctuation after it. Syntactically the sentence has ended, but the poem withholds a full stop, so the word hangs in white space. The next line, "people can be like that, too," starts in lowercase, as if the thought were slipping in unannounced. That is the poem's central trick in small: a danger enters without being marked as one.

The vocabulary is worth a look as well. The opening is deliberately casual: "Someone once told me that," "actually," the plural "none of us are." It sounds like talk overheard in a car at night. Against that, "conceals" and "registering" are cooler, more clinical words. "Registering" especially belongs to instruments and records, not feelings, and it gives the poem a detached, almost analytical tone. The speaker explains the fear calmly, which may be how people cope with a lesson they learned the hard way. That is only an inference from the tone, but the controlled language beside the unsettling idea gives the poem its quiet tension. Even the slightly odd phrase "right before eyes," with no "my" or "your" attached, makes the eyes anyone's, so the warning applies to every reader.

The poem is worth reading because it is so compact. In ten short lines it takes one of the first fears most of us have, the fear of the dark, and shows it carrying an adult fear underneath: misjudging someone we trust, or someone who simply stands near us. It offers no advice and no comfort. It leaves a thought in the reader's mind, like a figure just at the edge of the light.

Read also

More by victor

All poems
Sadvictor

* * *

And every time you wanted to cry. Every time you wanted to die. I was there. I was there for you.
Sadvictor

* * *

I remember when I was younger, I would see people with dull eyes but happy faces. And I couldn't understand why. I remember when I was younger I saw a girl with scars on her arms. And my mom said that she did that too herself.
Sadvictor

* * *

There it is again That all so welcoming pain The hurt The drowning