A Person, A Memory From Ashes to Nothing — Poem analysis

When I die, Let my body go to ashes The same way I was born from And throw me into the river Where miss and fern Gloss and grow over it And pray That only the waters Make it disappear And leave no evidence Of my existence Not even in memory Or a spec of ash

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most poems about death plead to be remembered. Willowsails does the reverse. The speaker gives funeral instructions: burn the body, scatter it in a river, and then hope the water erases everything, including the memory of the person who lived. The central idea is a wish for complete disappearance, and it unsettles us because it overturns the usual comfort that the dead live on in those who loved them. The subtitle, "A Person, A Memory From Ashes to Nothing," lays out the whole journey in advance: a person becomes a memory, the memory becomes ashes, and the ashes become nothing.

The poem is a single stanza of thirteen lines with almost no punctuation. The only comma comes after "When I die," and there is no full stop at the end, so the words seem to drift on like a current. There is no regular rhyme or meter. The lines are short and plain, and their rhythm comes from repetition. Three lines begin with "And" ("And throw me," "And pray," "And leave no evidence"), which gives the poem the feel of a list of instructions, close to a will. The verbs are imperatives: "Let," "throw," "pray." The speaker is in charge of the arrangements, but only until the moment of death. There is one quiet sound-echo, too: "evidence / Of my existence" chime across a line break, as if the two words were being tied together just before they are cancelled.

The imagery is small and natural. The speaker chooses a river and plants rather than a grave or a monument. "Miss and fern" is presumably a slip for "moss and fern," since moss fits the damp riverbank, and the plants "Gloss and grow over it." "Gloss" is a rich word here. It suggests a green shine on the leaves, but "to gloss over" also means to cover up and smooth away. Nature, then, is invited to hide the remains, softly and without fuss. What "it" refers to is left open: the ashes, the body, or perhaps the whole fact of the speaker's death. That vagueness suits a poem about leaving no clear mark.

The word "pray" gets a line to itself, and it is the poem's turning point. Prayer usually asks for salvation or remembrance. Here it asks for the opposite, that "only the waters / Make it disappear." The word "only" matters. The speaker is happy for ferns to grow over the ashes, since plants don't remember anyone, but the final erasing is handed to the water.

From there the poem shrinks step by step. The body becomes ashes, the ashes go into the river, and the river takes away "evidence," then "existence," then "memory." The last line reaches the smallest unit possible, "a spec of ash." (Probably "speck," though the missing letter makes the word look even tinier on the page.) Ash also returns us to line two, so the poem ends where its subject began. The line "Not even in memory" is the sharpest of all, because memory is the one place mourners expect to keep the dead. The subtitle's "From Ashes to Nothing" also seems to bend the familiar phrase "ashes to ashes," where ashes are an ending that still has a shape. Here even that shape is taken away.

One more detail adds to the effect. "The same way I was born from" stops on a preposition, with nothing after it. The sentence is left unfinished, and it hints that the speaker came from ashes too. Whatever the intended meaning, the broken grammar mirrors the theme of something trailing off into absence.

The poem's significance lies in its tension. It asks for total forgetting, yet it exists, and every reader who finishes it has, in a small way, remembered the speaker. Is the wish humble, weary, peaceful, or sad? Willowsails gives no reason, and the text doesn't settle it, which makes the poem a good one to argue over. What it does show, in very few words, is how strange it is to ask for nothing to be left behind.

Read also

More by Willowsails

All poems
RomanticWillowsails

This Type of Love is Different

Perhaps since I was a boy I never knew what "this" type of love was like Maybe "love" was a facade But when he kisses my cheek