Palilalia — Poem analysis

of course i always planned to finish college but instead i returned home like the parabolic parodical son with no degree and a lingering fear of schools

grandpa too had a nervous breakdown in college smart and dilligent as he was and now he’s a drop-out with a good pension and shelves of books on medieval warfare

even when history doesn’t mean to repeat itself it stammers stutters and says the same words again in an unconscious whisper like i would when i was seven

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A title like "Palilalia" sends you to the dictionary, and what you find there is the key to the poem. The word names a speech condition in which a person repeats their own words or phrases. Dominique Cyprès uses it as a metaphor. The poem is about a family pattern: a grandfather who broke down at college, and a grandchild who has now come home from college without a degree. The central idea is that history repeats itself the way a stammer does, without planning or intending it, and that this can be gentler and more forgivable than it first sounds.

The first stanza opens with a defensive little phrase, "of course i always planned to finish college", which sounds like someone rehearsing an excuse. Then comes the poem's cleverest moment: the speaker returns home "like / the parabolic parodical son." The phrase plays on the prodigal son of the biblical parable, and the pile-up of p-sounds echoes the title's own repeating syllables. "Parabolic" works twice. It points to the parable, and it also suggests a parabola, the curve that travels out and swings back to where it began. "Parodical" admits that this is a cheap copy of the original story, since this son returns with "no degree" and no fortune squandered, only "a lingering fear of schools." The word "lingering" is well chosen, because the fear stays behind like a sound that hasn't quite faded.

The second stanza turns to grandpa, and the tone becomes oddly tender. The poem gives him a "nervous breakdown in college" and then describes him as "smart and" diligent, so that his ability seems to make the collapse more surprising. Then comes the blunt label "drop-out", softened at once by "a good pension / and shelves of books on medieval warfare." The detail is funny and moving at once. The grandfather has turned his failure into a quiet life of reading about distant battles. Judging by the imagery, those shelves suggest an old struggle that never quite went away and was only redirected. They also set up the final stanza, since a man surrounded by history books is the family's own small example of history. The word "college" is repeated from the first stanza, so the poem stutters even as it describes stuttering.

The last stanza steps back to make a general claim: "even when history doesn't mean / to repeat itself / it stammers stutters." The missing comma between "stammers" and "stutters" lets the two verbs jam together, and the line break after "mean" leaves the word hanging, as though the sentence itself hesitates. "Unconscious whisper" matters too. It suggests that nobody chooses this repetition, and that blame is the wrong response to something that happens below the level of intention. The final line, "like / i would when i was seven," shrinks the whole sweep of history down to one child. It also hints that the speaker has been here before, murmuring the same words over, and that coming home has returned them to an earlier self.

The form matches this smallness. There is no rhyme and no regular meter. The poem is free verse in three stanzas of five, six and six lines, with no full stops and with lowercase letters even for "i" and "grandpa." That lack of capitals and punctuation gives the voice a hushed, confessional quality, close to the whisper of the last stanza. The poem also moves in a loop: it begins with the speaker, passes through the grandfather, widens to history, and lands on the speaker as a child. Like the parabola hidden in the second line, it curves out and returns.

The poem matters because it handles a painful subject, a breakdown and a sense of failure, without melodrama. It avoids tragedy and self-pity, choosing wit, wordplay and a calm, wry tone. By setting the grandfather's pension and bookshelves beside the speaker's fear, it suggests that a repeated pattern is not a sentence to be served. A stammer can be survived, and a person who stammers can still have a good life afterward.

Read also

More by Dominique Cyprès

All poems
DreamyDominique Cyprès

Dawn Chorus

we saw thick clouds swirling malignant on the dopplar all morning but by the time you were swaddled in your carseat the sky was clearing leaving
DreamyDominique Cyprès

Battered by the Rain

battered by the rain bowled over by the wind supplicant to winter snows and sizzled by the summer sun
SadDominique Cyprès

Star of Wonder

fighting a strong gust of wind along madison avenue and peering through the frost on my glasses