A Precocious Existentialism — Poem analysis

she had the night shift when i was little before work she put me to bed and told me a story about sad apes who locked themselves in boxes without fruit that was the only subject of any story worth telling

she left my room and the crickets chirped the stars appeared to rotate slowly around the makeshift plastic-coated wooden slide my father had built in the backyard the moon shone and small as i was i knew it was lit by the nearest star burning itself out

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Bedtime is supposed to shut the world out, but here it lets the whole universe in. A mother leaves for her night shift after tucking her child in, and the story she tells is not a gentle one. It is about "sad apes / who locked themselves in boxes without fruit." The child, now the adult speaker looking back, goes on to lie in the dark and think about stars dying. The poem's central idea is that the knowledge that things end and that existence can be bleak does not wait for adulthood. It can arrive early, in the middle of ordinary family life, and the poem treats this with a calm that is both funny and unsettling.

The title, "A Precocious Existentialism," sets the tone. It is a grown-up, slightly mock-academic phrase for what is really a small child's experience. The first stanza backs this up by stating a dry verdict: the sad-ape story "was the only subject / of any story worth telling." The line break after "subject" gives the sentence a deadpan pause. It is hard to tell whether this is the mother's view, the child's, or the adult speaker's later judgement. That vagueness helps the poem, because the pessimism seems to be part of the household's air rather than one person's opinion.

The ape fable is the poem's most inventive image. Apes are close enough to us to stand in for humans, and the detail that they locked themselves in boxes suggests a trap people build for themselves, not one imposed from outside. The missing fruit is a lovely, odd touch. It makes the apes' misery come from the absence of simple pleasure, not from some grand tragedy, and it keeps the fable childlike while the meaning underneath is not.

The second stanza moves from the story to the real night outside. The crickets are an ordinary, comforting sound, and the stars "appeared to rotate slowly," a phrase that quietly separates appearance from truth. That separation matters, because the child here is a knower as well as a watcher. The most striking detail is the slide, which is "makeshift," "plastic-coated," and "wooden," built by the father in the backyard. It is a small, homemade, slightly fragile object, set against the whole turning sky. The stars seem to circle it, as if the child's world were the centre, but the piled-up adjectives make the slide look improvised and temporary. Love is present in the poem, in the mother's story and the father's carpentry, but it is practical and makeshift, and it sits under an enormous indifferent sky.

The final sentence carries the most weight: "the moon shone and small as i was / i knew it was lit by the nearest star / burning itself out." The enjambment after "was" makes the child's smallness a concession, as in *small as I was, I still understood*. The poem never names the sun. "The nearest star" makes it just one more star, and it removes the cosy, familiar name. The moon is shining on borrowed light, and the source of that light is consuming itself. The last words, "burning itself out," fall away on a stressed, final "out," and with no closing punctuation the thought is left open.

The form supports all of this. There is no rhyme, no punctuation, and no capital letters, even for "i." The lowercase pronoun shrinks the speaker to the size of the child being described, and the lack of full stops gives the lines the drift of memory, or of a mind that cannot sleep. The language is plain and conversational throughout, which makes the cosmic facts hit harder. Nothing is dramatised and no one panics.

The poem's significance lies in this combination of tenderness and dread. It does not say that the child was unhappy, and it gives us no more about the family than the details it chooses. Instead it shows how a person can be loved and cared for and still be quietly aware that everything, including the light by which we see, is running down. The poem's humour is the way it survives this thought.

Read also

More by Dominique Cyprès

All poems
ContemplativeDominique Cyprès

Disintegration of the Self

i was an empty room with an open window lived and breathed in empty stairwells
DreamyDominique Cyprès

Battered by the Rain

battered by the rain bowled over by the wind supplicant to winter snows and sizzled by the summer sun
SadDominique Cyprès

Star of Wonder

fighting a strong gust of wind along madison avenue and peering through the frost on my glasses