«you have watched me…» — Poem analysis

you have watched me bloom fall die then bloom again

now watch my petals slowly fall off delicately, softly.

i am slowly dying once more in ways i cannot bloom again-

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Flowers usually come with a promise: whatever happens in winter, the bloom will return. That is why poets so often use them to talk about hope. eimaan's twelve-line poem borrows the promise and then quietly takes it back. The speaker has already been through a cycle of flowering and ruin, and has come back from it once. Now she or he asks the listener to watch a different kind of ending, one that the old pattern of recovery cannot reverse.

The first stanza is built like a quick montage. "You have watched me / bloom / fall / die / then bloom again." Most of the lines are a single word, stacked down the page, so the eye drops from "bloom" to "fall" to "die" the way a petal would. There is no punctuation at all, which makes the whole cycle feel like one breath. It also sounds almost casual. Death sits in the middle of the list as just another stage, quickly followed by "then bloom again." The speaker is summing up a history in which the worst has already happened and been survived.

The second stanza slows everything down. The poem turns from "you have watched" to a command: "now watch my petals / slowly fall off." It is an odd mix of invitation and challenge. The speaker is exposed, yet also directs the viewer, as if saying that if you saw me return, you should see this too. Where the first stanza squeezed an entire cycle into five lines, this one stretches a single falling over four. Punctuation appears for the first time, a comma after "delicately" and a full stop after "softly," and each mark is a small pause. The two adverbs are nearly synonyms, and with "slowly" they make a hushed, murmuring run of *-ly* endings and soft *s* and *l* sounds. The gentleness is the unsettling part. Nothing is violent or dramatic here. The loss is described in the vocabulary of tenderness, and that makes it feel more final than a cry would.

The last stanza is where the poem turns on its own opening. "Again" first appeared as comfort, in "bloom again." It returns at the very end in the negative: "i cannot bloom again." The same word now closes a door it once held open. "Once more" also echoes the earlier cycle, but this time the dying has no promised second half. The line break after "in ways" is worth lingering on. For a moment the phrase stands alone, hinting that there is more than one way of dying, and that the speaker is losing several things at once. Then the sentence continues and the grammar tightens, so "in ways i cannot bloom again" reads as dying in ways from which there is no return. The poem also ends on a hyphen, not a full stop. The sentence is cut off, as though the speaker has run out of words, or of strength, before reaching a conclusion. After the tidy punctuation of the second stanza, this open ending feels deliberate: the poem simply stops, as the speaker may be stopping.

The poem has no rhyme and no regular meter. Its music comes from line length, repetition ("fall," "slowly," "again") and the shrinking stanzas, which go from five lines to four to three, as if the poem itself were running down. The lowercase "i" keeps the speaker small and close, and the title is only a row of asterisks, a mark that leaves the poem unnamed, which fits a text that never says what is dying. The poem does not say who "you" is, and it does not say what the dying is. A relationship, a hope or a sense of self would all fit the imagery, and judging by the text alone, that openness is deliberate.

What makes the poem worth reading is its refusal of the comforting story. Plenty of writing about hardship insists that people always bloom again. eimaan allows that someone can recover once, perhaps twice, and still reach a point where recovery is no longer on offer. The poem does not argue this or plead for pity. It asks to be watched, patiently and softly, and in that quiet request lies most of its force.

Read also

More by eimaan

All poems
Angryeimaan

* * *

you choked me getting yourself in the habit of forcing the music out of me until i messed up on a note,
Dreamyeimaan

* * *

you know i can't dance but you should see these words when you're gone they dance thinking only of you-
Angryeimaan

* * *

you have taken all of me yet you still crave more-