«his voice…» — Poem analysis

eimaanRomantic

his voice makes me fall on my knees shattered with bitter taste but a small part of me never wants to stop hearing it-


i fear i will never hear it again

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Seven short lines, and the whole poem hangs on a single sound: a man's voice. The speaker never tells us who he is, what he said, or why it has this effect. All we get is the effect itself. His voice brings her to her knees, leaves her "shattered" with a "bitter taste," and yet some part of her cannot bear the thought of its stopping. The central idea is that pain and attachment can be tangled together so tightly that the thing which hurts is also the thing you cannot lose. The last line shows that the real terror is not the voice but its absence.

The poem opens with "his voice," and it is worth noticing what the speaker leaves out. She doesn't say "he hurts me" or "he speaks to me." The voice is the subject of the sentence, almost a force acting on her from outside, and that gives it a power greater than a person's. "Fall on my knees" is a physical image, but it also has the posture of prayer or surrender. Whether she kneels in devotion or in defeat is left open, and the poem seems to want both readings. The name attached to the poem, eimaan, resembles the word for faith in Urdu and Arabic. I can't say what that means for the poem, but the language of kneeling does sit well beside it.

The form acts out the breakdown the words describe. The lines are short and lowercase, with no capital letters and almost no punctuation. "Shattered" gets a line to itself, and the single word looks broken off from everything around it. The line lengths shift too. After the clipped opening, "with bitter taste" is only four syllables, but the lines then grow: "but a small part of me" is longer, "never wants to stop hearing it" longer again, and the last line longest of all. It is as if the speaker, once knocked down, slowly finds enough breath to confess. The poem has no rhyme, but small echoes hold it together. "Fall" in the second line is answered by "small" in the fifth, and "knees" by "me," so that the collapse of the body and the shrinking of the self quietly rhyme.

"Bitter taste" is the most surprising image. A voice is something we hear, not taste, and mixing the senses makes the sound feel swallowed, as though the words have gone into her body like medicine or poison. Judging by the imagery, the voice may carry harshness or disappointment, but the poem never says so. That restraint keeps the poem open to many situations: a lover, a parent, a friend, someone already gone.

The turn comes at "but a small part of me." The word "small" is quietly paradoxical, because this small part wins the argument. It controls the second half of the poem and outweighs the shattered whole. The speaker is divided, and she knows which half is more honest. The ending also leans on repetition: "never wants to stop hearing it" is mirrored by "will never hear it again." The same word faces two ways. First "never" is a wish, that the voice should go on forever. Then it is a threat, that it will not return. Desire and fear turn out to be the same feeling seen from opposite sides.

The punctuation helps with this. The line before the last ends in a hyphen, and the final line begins with a dash, so a small typographical gap sits between the confession and the fear. It reads like a pause to swallow, or a hesitation before saying the worse thing aloud. The last line is also the only one that looks forward, shifting from what the voice does now to what its silence will do later. Even the title, three asterisks, suggests a poem that was never given a name, as if it were a thought caught in mid-flight.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it holds in so little space. It does not explain the pain or blame anyone, and it does not pretend the speaker should simply walk away. It admits something many people recognise and few say plainly: we can be hurt by what we most need to hear. The poem ends not on the hurt, but on the fear of silence, which says more about the speaker's feelings than any description of the man could.

Read also

More by eimaan

All poems
Angryeimaan

* * *

you choked me getting yourself in the habit of forcing the music out of me until i messed up on a note,
Romanticeimaan

* * *

when i'm with you i am either blinded or mesmorized- because you're the sun
Angryeimaan

* * *

my throat is burning from the poison you