Dignity — Poem analysis

The Seagulls used to be Angels according to a Nordic legend that I probably don't understand.

They have become this way, it seems, because we simply, slowly forgot about them.

& as I stand outside in the warm night smoking, I can hear them squawking a seething, teeming mass of white feathers

& cold hard beaks poking at discarded styrofoam chip boxes, ketchup packets & chicken bones:

all the detritus out here by the coast in one of so many forgotten towns…

The thought that these strangely mechanical seeming beasts could once have been our sublime idols seems oddly appropriate:

Now that we have desire as disposable convenience what need do we have for the Magnificat;

for prayer or pilgrimage, supplication, meditation & incense or any attempt, no matter how naive to transcend the brutish fact of materiality; existence & mortality?

So the seagulls scrabble among our waste like avian beggars, safe only because wings bring freedom, & ignored or else quietly despised by the normal & respectably employed,

like the homeless people who hide & die behind the houses & in the filthy streets.

Dignity is denied to the forgotten.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A speaker steps outside for a cigarette on a warm night in a run-down seaside town and listens to gulls fighting over leftovers. From that ordinary scene the poem builds a bleak argument. A society that has stopped believing in anything beyond appetite throws away its sacred things and its vulnerable people in the same careless way. Dignity, the final line suggests, is not something a creature simply has. It is something others grant by paying attention, and withdraw by forgetting.

The opening is carefully unshowy. The Nordic legend that makes seagulls fallen angels comes with a confession: "that / I probably don't understand." The speaker never claims authority over the myth, and the poem doesn't need it to be accurate. It works as a lens, a way of asking what happens when something once revered is neglected. The answer arrives in a soft, guilty phrase: "we simply, / slowly / forgot about them." The indented "slowly" drifts away from the margin, enacting the gradual loss it describes. Nobody in this story is a villain, and that is what makes it uncomfortable.

The imagery then turns harsh. The gulls are "a seething, teeming mass of white feathers / & cold hard beaks," and the repeated *-ing* sounds make the flock seem to boil. The white feathers still carry a faint memory of angelic purity, but the beaks are "cold hard," and the birds are "strangely mechanical seeming beasts," creatures that have lost whatever made them luminous. What they feed on is listed in short, cheap-sounding items: "styrofoam chip boxes, / ketchup packets / & chicken bones." Each item sits on its own line, like something dropped on the pavement. There is a grim touch, too, in birds picking over the bones of another bird.

The central turn comes with the line "desire as disposable convenience." Here the poem sets two lists against each other. The first is litter. The second is worship: "prayer or pilgrimage, / supplication, meditation & incense," topped by the Magnificat, a word chosen for its grandeur. The speaker is not simply preaching. He concedes that such practices might be "naive," yet he still values them as attempts "to transcend the brutish fact / of materiality; / existence & mortality." The long question trails off without a question mark. It reads less like a challenge than a sigh, as if the speaker already knows the answer.

Then the metaphor widens. The gulls become "avian beggars," and the poem slides into its real subject: "like the homeless people / who hide & die / behind the houses." The gulls are "safe / only because wings bring freedom," a detail that quietly shows what the people lack. The scorn of those who ignore or "quietly despise" them is built into the phrase "the normal / & respectably employed," where the stress on normal and respectable is faintly sarcastic. "Hide & die" is one of the few places the poem comes near rhyme. The sound pairing makes the two verbs feel like a single, unnoticed event.

Formally, the poem is free verse with no rhyme scheme. It leans on conversational phrasing, ampersands and stray indentation, so it sounds like thought rather than performance. Scattered sound patterns do the work rhyme might otherwise do: "seething, teeming," "chip boxes," "chicken bones," "wings bring freedom." The ellipsis after "forgotten towns…" lets the sentence trail off, as if the places themselves were fading. After all this hedging ("it seems," "probably"), the last line is flat and certain: "Dignity is denied to the forgotten." It also gives the title its irony, since dignity is the one thing the poem has shown nobody receiving.

What makes the poem worth reading is its refusal to flatter anyone, including the speaker. He stands in the same night, among the same waste, and says "our" and "we," not "they." The gulls and the homeless are not offered up for pity so much as for recognition. The poem asks us to notice what we have trained ourselves to walk past, and suggests that this habit of not noticing is how dignity gets lost.

Read also

More by wordsforghosts

All poems
Sadwordsforghosts

The marionette parade

Dragging behind you every decision & memory: a ragged procession of skeletal marionettes;
Contemplativewordsforghosts

All of this is temporary

The City swells with life & you, insignificant, stare at the people & the buildings