Why Can’t We Be Direct? — Summary

Why can’t we be direct?

If you hate me maybe it’s just for the best.

Why can’t we be direct?

If you love me, kiss me with no regrets.

Why can’t we be direct?

If you don’t know, can we be confused together? Doesn’t mean we have to be fused forever.

Why can’t we be direct?

Always worried that there’s some kind of secret test. Why can’t we be direct?

Does he ever tell you how he feels?

Because I’m dying outside of your magnetic field.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The speaker keeps repeating one plea: why can't we just say what we mean? Between each repetition, the options pile up. If you hate me, fine, it might be for the best. If you love me, kiss me without holding back. If you're unsure, then be unsure together, because confusion doesn't have to turn into a lifelong commitment. The tone is casual and a little wry, but the repeated question gives it an edge of frustration.

Underneath that, the speaker seems anxious. Relationships feel like "some kind of secret test," where everyone is guessing at the right move. Then the poem turns. The question about whether "he" ever tells you how he feels suggests a third person, maybe a partner who stays silent. The last line drops the joking and admits real need: the speaker is "dying outside of your magnetic field." The mood moves from restless and playful to vulnerable and pleading, as if the demand for directness was really a way of asking to be pulled closer.

Read also

More by Jason Ridpath

All poems
AnxiousJason Ridpath

For Sale

Sell me pieces of your life. Trinkets for me to gorge upon. Crows pecking on your skull. Existing evermore beyond the light.
AnxiousJason Ridpath

Loops in Time

Travel through the swirly mess. Upside down, right side up, another test. Back, slide, and flipped. Head smashed in.
AnxiousJason Ridpath

Will It All Be Okay Tomorrow?

Will the trampoline be secure. Will the lamppost fall on my car. Will the tiles stay on the roof. Will the wind stop howling.