Too Much Butter, Not Enough Bread — Summary

I lived in a cave during the winter of 2019 Never once wandering into the daylight Took a vow of silence that year Memorized 10,000 Buddhist sutras

Quit eating carbohydrates Swore off meat and dairy Fasted for six months Surviving on ten sunflower seeds And a cupped handful of water per day Until I almost died

For all the good it did

I should have volunteered to work At the local soup kitchen

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The speaker lists a series of punishing spiritual feats: living in a cave through a winter, staying silent, memorizing thousands of sutras, giving up carbs, meat and dairy, and fasting down to ten sunflower seeds a day. It reads like a résumé of self-denial, and the flat, matter-of-fact tone makes it sound almost like bragging. Then comes the drop. The speaker nearly dies, and the verdict is a shrug: "For all the good it did."

The last two lines turn everything around. Instead of retreating from the world, the speaker says they should have helped in a soup kitchen, feeding other people. The poem seems to suggest that real goodness lies in practical kindness, not in dramatic suffering done alone. The mood is dry, wry and a little rueful, with humor in the understatement. The title, with its odd mix of too much and not enough, hints at the same imbalance: excess on one side, and something basic missing on the other.

Read also

More by J. Martin Strangeweather

All poems
AnxiousJ. Martin Strangeweather

Peek-A-Boo

Your mind is not hiding somewhere between your ears. Your mind isn’t even yours. We’re all sharing it.
ContemplativeJ. Martin Strangeweather

As Good a Reason as Any for Compassion

studies comparing brain scans of people before and after they had COVID reveal the loss of between 0.2% and 2.0% of brain matter
CheerfulJ. Martin Strangeweather

Building a Better Bomb

“Wake up, dear. It’s time to go to school.” “Aw, I don’t wanna.” “But you have to, dear. You’re the teacher.” The words are dead. The sentences came out stillborn,