Upon the Hour — Poem analysis

In the loneliness and neglect; And in yearning for what we don’t possess — Most of love only vaguely cedes.

Life slips away in retrospect,

To wish for days one ever forgets — A truth of love that never leaves.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Read the title and the first line together and the poem's grammar begins to make sense: "Upon the hour / In the loneliness and neglect." The sentence starts before the poem seems to, as if the reader has walked into the middle of a thought. That is fitting, because the poem is about things that arrive late and incomplete. Its central idea, as I read it, is that love is known less through presence than through absence. It lives in loneliness, neglect and wanting, and we understand it only in hindsight, when the days it belonged to are already gone.

The first stanza gives love an unromantic home. It sits "in the loneliness and neglect" and "in yearning for what we don't possess." Nothing here is warm or fulfilled. Then comes the odd, formal verb: "Most of love only vaguely cedes." To cede is to hand something over, as a country cedes territory, usually reluctantly and under pressure. Love, in other words, gives up its meaning grudgingly. "Vaguely" blurs the sentence just as it describes blurring, and "Most of love" admits that the greater part of the feeling never becomes clear.

Then the poem does something visual. "Life slips away in retrospect," stands alone, a single line with white space above and below. The verb "slips" suggests something lost without effort or notice, and "retrospect" explains why. We see life clearly only when looking back, by which time it has gone. The comma at the end keeps the line from closing, so the thought tips forward into the final couplet.

That couplet holds the poem's sharpest paradox: "To wish for days one ever forgets." How can anyone wish for days they have forgotten? The line suggests that the wanting survives even when the memory does not. It also shifts pronouns. In the second line the speaker says "we," but here it is the cooler, more detached "one," as though the experience has moved from shared to private, or from felt to observed. The last line, "A truth of love that never leaves," reverses the poem's vocabulary. "Cedes," "slips away," "forgets" are all words of departure, and the final word, "leaves," arrives only to be denied. Everything else goes, but the ache of wishing stays.

The sound of the poem supports this. Most lines run to about eight syllables, but the second stretches to ten ("And in yearning for what we don't possess"), so the line grows as the wanting does. The rhymes are loose and uneven. "Neglect" and "retrospect" are a true rhyme, and they tie the opening line to the lonely single line, so that loneliness and hindsight sound like the same condition. "Forgets" carries the same closing *-t* sound, which helps to link the poem's beginning and end. But "cedes" and "leaves" only half-rhyme, sharing a long *e* and a soft closing hiss or buzz while the consonants differ. The poem's biggest closing gesture therefore almost, but not quite, clicks shut, which suits a poem about incompleteness. The stanza shape, three lines then one then two, also seems to thin out as it goes, like something fading.

Two dashes, at the ends of lines 2 and 7, each prepare a kind of verdict. The first leads to "Most of love," the second to "A truth of love." That small shift, from "most of," which is partial and uncertain, to "a truth," which is singular and settled, may be the poem's quiet turning point. Out of all the vagueness, one thing is allowed to be certain.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it does not console. It does not claim that love fulfils us or that memory preserves what matters. It offers a stranger comfort, that the longing itself is reliable. Its fractured sentences also make the reader do some of the work, since the grammar is loose enough to allow more than one reading. We have to fill the gaps, much as the speaker fills the missing days with wishing. In under fifty words, the poem makes the reader feel that experience of looking back and finding less than was there, and yet still wanting it.

Read also

More by J.J. Loe

All poems
ContemplativeJ.J. Loe

The Pearl

Time is a vandal entering the clam of the heart as though a grain of sand. It is our long irritation with it that slowly forms the pearl of invention.
RomanticJ.J. Loe

First Blush

In my blue morning fantasies — Foxes run across your wild mouth / misty plumes swell from the cunning of your brow. With your eyes enblazed with ineffable winds
AnxiousJ.J. Loe

(1943)

That year the sea rose slowly from the plain / crashing into life swollen as an infant. — A thing of its own shadow traced out of the ripple. — Salt white over red sand passed from bosom into hand.