Is This It? #1 — Summary

Is this how it all ends.

Asking less and less from life.

Hearing little of the sounds around you.

Saying less or nothing at all.

Wearing a Cheshire cat’s grin?

No heroic gesture.

No stoic stance.

No wisdom to guide us through This breathless darkness?

No quiet dignity?

Where is the truth in all this?

Is there none at all at the end?

Only to be held and kissed Until you slide softly away from us?

Where are the roar and the thunder

That would have leapt from your mouth and hands

If it had been one of us?

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Almost every line here is a question, and the questions sound like grief looking for something to push against. The speaker watches someone fade: they ask for less, hear less, say less, and wear a strange fixed smile. The speaker seems to want a grand ending, with a brave gesture, a calm stance, some wisdom to pass on, but gets none of it. What they get is gentler and harder to accept: the person is held and kissed as they "slide softly away."

The feeling underneath is bewilderment, and maybe a little anger. The last lines make this clearest. The speaker imagines the dying person's usual "roar and thunder" and says it would have burst out if the situation were reversed, if it had been "one of us" dying. That suggests the speaker is mourning the loss of a forceful presence, and struggling to see how such a person could go so quietly.

The mood is hushed, tender and unsettled. Short, plain lines leave space for silence, and the unanswered questions leave us in that silence too.

Read also

More by Mike Stone

All poems
ContemplativeMike Stone

Moral Dilemmas 1

What if they were one of us? What if we were one of them? What if you were me? What if I were you?
ContemplativeMike Stone

Moral Dilemmas 7

Sometimes I wonder what I really know for sure. I'm not so sure that what I think I know for sure is really true. I don't even believe for certain that what I believe is what is. I know that my knowledge is grounded in what I believe.
RomanticMike Stone

Cupped Body

Holding your touch in my cupped body Burning is being Above the ripples in Adam’s pond And the child who cast the first stone.