Moral Dilemmas 4 — Summary

Mike StoneAnxious

I'm walking along the street.

I see a young and pretty woman With an infant in her arms.

There is a sign beside her requesting alms.

Should I give her some money?

How much should I give her?

What if it's not enough?

Should I give her everything I have on me?

What if I see someone else in need down the street?

Maybe I should give her nothing and walk on by.

Maybe I should have thought about this before I left my hotel And taken enough spare change for everyone in need.

How much would that be?

Two? Five? Ten? A hundred? A million?

What if I don't see them along the street I'm walking?

What if it's an old lady without an infant?

What if it's a man who doesn't smell very good?

What if he's deformed?

What if she's wearing a burkal

What if the infant grows up to be a terrorist?

What if, instead of money, she asks me for the time of day?

What if she's smartly dressed and self-confident?

What if she asks me for my love?

What if I don't have any to give?

What if it's not enough?

What if it all belongs to my wife?

What if it's infinite?

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A man walking down a street sees a woman begging with a baby, and instead of reaching for his wallet, he starts to question himself. How much is enough? What if someone worse off is around the corner? The poem is made almost entirely of these questions, and it shows a mind that talks itself out of acting.

The questions start out practical, then drift into something uglier. The speaker wonders whether he would feel the same if the beggar were old, smelly, deformed, or wearing a burqa. He even imagines the baby growing into a terrorist. These thoughts expose prejudices he seems half-ashamed of, yet he voices them anyway. Then the poem shifts: what if she asked for his love, and he had none to give? The money problem turns into a question about whether he can give anything of himself.

The mood is anxious, awkward, and a little darkly comic. The short, flat lines make his panic feel real, and the closing "What if it's infinite?" suggests need that can never be fully met.

Read also

More by Mike Stone

All poems
CheerfulMike Stone

Noellen

Noellen, I say and then stop because love is the silent saying and saying of a single name. Instructions on how to say Noellen: Insert flap N into slot O
RomanticMike Stone

Night Watch

Sometimes when I come to bed at night I watch you sleep, wrapped up So tightly in your blankets And you're so beautiful that
SadMike Stone

Is This It? #1

Is this how it all ends. Asking less and less from life. Hearing little of the sounds around you. Saying less or nothing at all.