The Riot — Poem analysis

we only saw the images hot orange flames torching the dark structure the town had exploded mayhem and broken glass and hundreds of more fires crashed into the soup of unformed anger, the metaphors swam around in incandescent television scenes

there were thousands in the streets the stores picked like open closets and others burned to charcoal the country had wavered and then shook, the waves shivered from the west to the east and nothing mattered but the violence which cooked like steaming lava

what went wrong they all asked what happened who were the sinners? but no one could agree but for the web that wound like a silk robe around the smoldering city

the smoke staining the sky with black imprints, the air milled with words that stung and scattered and the ocean full of the souls that were now dead

we saw, we mourned

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nobody in Orrin Schwab's "The Riot" is standing in the street. The opening line settles that at once: "we only saw the images." The small word "only" makes the whole account second-hand. The riot arrives as "incandescent / television scenes," and the poem turns out to be less about the violence itself than about how a watching public takes it in, argues over it and finally grieves.

Schwab names no city, date or cause. There is only "the town" and "the country," so the riot reads as a pattern rather than a single case. The imagery is fierce but oddly domestic. Stores are "picked like open closets," as if looting were rummaging through a wardrobe. Anger is a "soup," and violence "cooked like / steaming lava." Kitchen words sit beside fire and volcano, and the clash unsettles. The catastrophe becomes familiar, almost consumable, which is arguably how television makes it. The poem seems to be quietly commenting on its own viewers.

The strangest moment comes when "the metaphors / swam around" in those television scenes. The poem admits it is making figures of speech and suggests the screen is making them too. Water then keeps surfacing. After the soup and the swimming, "the waves shivered from / the west to the east," and at the end comes "the ocean full of the souls / that were now dead." There is no ocean in a burning town, so judging by the imagery, the dead are dissolving into something vast and nameless. That fits the poem's habit of counting in crowds ("thousands in the streets," "hundreds of more fires") rather than in people.

The third stanza turns to the aftermath, and the talk is as unsettled as the fire. "what went wrong they all asked / what happened" tumbles out without punctuation, as if breathless, and only "who were the sinners?" gets a question mark. Blame arrives before understanding. The one thing everyone agrees on is "the web that wound / like a silk robe / around the smoldering city." The web could be the media, a network of talk, or something else, and the poem does not say. The silk robe is the sharper image. It is soft and comfortable, draped over a burning place. Afterwards the "air / milled with words that stung and scattered," and "milled" makes the words sound like a restless crowd. The smoke leaves "black imprints" on the sky, almost like type on a page. The talk has become a second kind of disturbance.

Formally, the poem is free verse with no rhyme and no steady metre. Its lines are short and often snap off on weak words: "crashed into the soup of / unformed anger." Breaking on "of," "the" or "and" leaves the reader tilting forward, a small stumble that mimics the rush of events. With lowercase lines and almost no punctuation, the first stanza reads as one long sentence. The sound work is subtle but audible. "Smoke staining the sky," "stung and scattered" and "smoldering city" all hiss like the fire they describe.

Then comes the final line, alone: "we saw, we mourned." It is the shortest line in the poem and the only one built from two matching verbs. It also echoes the opening "we only saw," so the poem ends where it began, with watching. The mourning is real, but the line asks what it amounts to. The poem does not say whether the speakers did anything beyond seeing and feeling, and the plural "we" makes the reader part of that silence. It can be read as a confession as much as a lament.

That is where the poem's significance lies. Because it is tied to no particular event, it describes a common modern experience: disaster reaches most of us as pictures, followed by questions, blame and grief, with little in between that counts as understanding. Schwab's images are vivid, but the poem is really about the distance behind them.

Read also

More by Orrin Schwab

All poems
DreamyOrrin Schwab

Nights

some nights uptown in Inwood the streets are colored in yellow light deserted by the time he was there the buildings reflected their age
AnxiousOrrin Schwab

In a Day

in a day he drove through the city, the city was rich and crowded, the neighborhoods fell into each other
ContemplativeOrrin Schwab

Waiting

the park soft green in March waits for the gentle spring sun to cure the grass of its shyness and for the