«A kid says…» — Poem analysis

A kid says my dog looks like his Grandmas dog.

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nobody in this scene says anything remarkable, and that is why it is worth stopping on. A kid offers a verdict: the speaker's dog looks like his grandma's dog. We are not told where this happens, how old the kid is, or how the speaker feels about it. The poem is ten words long, and almost everything in it is a comparison. Its central idea seems to be that we understand the world by hooking it to what we already know and love. The speaker's dog becomes visible to someone else only by being set beside another dog, in another household, belonging to a person we will never meet.

The construction is more careful than its casualness suggests. The first line, "A kid says," works like a stage direction: it sets up a speaker and then steps aside. The second line, "my dog looks," ends on a verb that hangs in the air. Here the line break does real work. For a moment "looks" means more than appearance. It is also the act of seeing, as if the kid is studying the dog. Then the third line completes the sentence with "like his Grandmas dog," and the expected description never arrives. We might have guessed the kid would say the dog looks like a wolf, a mop, or a bear. Instead he reaches for something small and domestic.

There is no rhyme and no regular meter, and the rhythm is that of overheard speech. Read aloud, the stresses fall roughly as A KID says / my DOG looks / like his GRANDmas DOG, so the poem swells slightly and ends on a firm beat. The word "dog" appears in the middle of line two and again at the very end. It does the job rhyme usually does, because the sound returns and closes the poem. Here it also repeats the idea of the poem: there are two dogs, and one word has to cover both. The lines grow from three words to three to four, a tiny widening, as if the sentence relaxes once it reaches its point. Nothing ends the poem, not even a full stop, so it feels less like a finished statement than a moment of conversation that carries on past the page.

The key words are plain, and most of them are possessives. "My dog" meets "his Grandmas dog," and the only bridge between the two is the small word "like." The poem is built from ownership and resemblance, and it makes both feel friendly rather than grand. The word "kid" is casual and anonymous, since this is not a named child but whoever happens to speak. The writing of "Grandmas" with a capital G and no apostrophe is hard to read with certainty. It may be deliberate, treating Grandma almost as a proper name, or simply a loose, speech-like way of setting the words down. Either way, the effect is a child's way of talking, in which a grandmother is a fixed and important person and not a general category.

The poem's imagery is interesting because it is borrowed. It gives us no breed, colour or size for either animal. Instead, the word "Grandma" lets each reader supply a picture from their own memory, perhaps a porch, a kitchen floor, or an old, well-fed pet who has the run of the house. The poem draws a picture without describing anything. Judging by the language, the dog is meant to feel familiar and a little humble, the sort of animal that belongs in a family.

What the poem leaves out is just as telling. We cannot tell whether the remark is a compliment, a joke or a mild insult. The speaker does not answer, and the poem stops before any reaction. A reader might hear affection in it, since to a child a grandmother's dog is probably a loved thing. Another reader might hear the sting of being told your pet looks like someone else's. The poem allows both readings and does not decide between them.

Its significance lies in this restraint. In three short lines it catches a moment so ordinary that most people would let it pass, and it shows how much feeling and uncertainty can sit inside a passing remark. It reminds us that being seen by another person, even clumsily and by comparison, is a strange small event. A poem does not need a grand subject to make a reader look twice.

Read also

More by Garret Schuelke

All poems
ContemplativeGarret Schuelke

* * *

A punching bag rests, waits, contemplating.
ContemplativeGarret Schuelke

* * *

Sitting in front of my old junior high, feeling good.
InspiredGarret Schuelke

* * *

Open my eyes— still dark out. A new day is here.