Refuge — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

I am resolved to flee to my sand castle

in which I may not fear anything but time or anger

I shall be bland as a discourse on ships

how dangerous it is to dally with a little doubt

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A sand castle is about the least dependable shelter anyone could pick, and Dave Bonta's "Refuge" lets us see that in its first two lines. The speaker announces, with the stiffness of a general issuing orders, that he is "resolved to flee," and then names his destination: "my sand castle." The joke lands at once and keeps working. A refuge should be solid, and this one will go with the first tide or the first careless foot. The central idea is that the urge to hide from the world is understandable but fragile, and that doubt, the thing the speaker most wants to shut out, is already inside the walls.

The second stanza sets the terms of the retreat. Inside the castle, the speaker says, "I may not fear anything / but time or anger." The phrase "may not fear" can be read two ways: as permission (I am allowed to fear nothing) or as a kind of rule (I must not fear). Either way, the exceptions are enormous. Time is the one thing nobody escapes, and for a castle of sand it means the tide and slow erosion. Anger could be someone else's, a boot kicking the towers down, or it could be the speaker's own. The line break helps here. "Anything" seems to promise total safety, and the short line that follows takes most of it back.

The form is plain and quiet. The poem is four couplets of free verse, with no rhyme and no punctuation at all. The lines are short, from four to eight syllables, and the vocabulary is mostly everyday and one-syllable, so the few formal words stand out. The first line break leaves "flee" alone at the end of its line, as if the speaker were already halfway out the door, and "to my sand castle" then arrives like a destination. A quieter sound effect links the first and third stanzas: "sand" comes back as "bland," so the dry, grainy, featureless quality of the place is carried into the speaker's chosen personality. There is also a hint, if you listen for it, in "resolved." The word means firmly decided, but it can also mean broken down into parts, which suits a castle that will not hold together.

In the third stanza the speaker says, "I shall be bland / as a discourse on ships." The solemn "shall" sounds like a vow, and the vow is to be dull. Blandness is the speaker's armor: if you show and feel nothing, nothing can get at you. The comparison is odd and well chosen. A discourse is a lecture or treatise, something talked about rather than lived. Ships, meanwhile, are things that leave, cross water and risk storms. Draining all that adventure into a dry talk suggests a man who would rather be a lecture about voyages than a voyager. Ships also belong to the sea, so the stanza quietly puts the beach around the castle, with the water close.

Then the poem changes voice. The "I" disappears and we get what sounds like a proverb: "how dangerous it is to dally / with a little doubt." It could be a line from the very discourse the speaker has promised to resemble. There is no exclamation mark, so the warning comes out deadpan. The words are carefully picked. "Dally" suggests flirting or idling, something casual, and "a little" doubt sounds harmless, yet the line insists on danger. The repeated d-sounds in "dangerous," "dally" and "doubt" make the warning sound like a chant.

The ending is where the poem turns on itself. Back in the second stanza, the speaker listed his only fears as time and anger. Doubt was not among them, yet it gets the last word. If he were truly settled in his refuge, he would not need to warn anyone, or himself, against it. The fact that he does suggests that doubt is already at work, and that the opening resolve was an attempt to talk himself into something. With no full stop, the poem ends on "doubt" and simply stops, leaving it unresolved.

The poem's significance lies in how much it does in about thirty words. It is funny and a little sad at once, and it never explains itself. It captures the way people argue themselves into withdrawal, with firm declarations, a dull disguise and a shelter that cannot last, while the real trouble is the hesitation they were trying to escape. The reader is left to decide whether the speaker will stay in the castle, or whether he has already begun to leave it.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss