Disproportionate — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

change and strange times cause conversation full of glass

some committee is stuck in my mind all evening

how to clear myself of late nights

the stars as high as they seem sting our hands

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Eight short lines, no capital letters, no punctuation, and Dave Bonta's "Disproportionate" still travels from the state of the age to the inside of one sleepless head and out to the night sky. Its central idea is mismatched scale. Big things hurt with the sharpness of small ones, and small worries swell until they fill a whole evening. The title names the condition the poem never stops showing.

The first couplet opens with a chime: "change and strange times." The words "change" and "strange" nearly rhyme, so the phrase sounds almost like a saying, the kind of thing people murmur in any unsettled period. Then comes the surprise: such times "cause conversation full of glass." Glass is transparent, brittle and sharp, and the image suggests talk in which everyone is careful, and any remark might shatter or cut. The odd little phrase "full of glass" makes speech feel like a bag of fragments. The hissing s and c sounds ("cause," "conversation," "glass") give the line a faint crunch.

Then the poem shrinks sharply. After the vast "times" we get "some committee," an image from the dullest corner of working life. The committee "is stuck / in my mind all evening," and the line break lets "stuck" end its line, so the sentence itself stalls. The committee suggests a deadlocked meeting running past its hour, with no vote and no adjournment. There is dry humour here, but also unease: the mind has become a boardroom the speaker cannot leave. The drop from historical change to office procedure is the first real disproportion.

The third couplet, "how to clear myself / of late nights," has no question mark, so the question simply hangs. "Clear" does several jobs at once. It can mean being cleared of blame, as if the late nights were an accusation. It can mean sweeping away debris, which links back to the broken glass. And it can mean a clear sky, which prepares for the ending. Judging by the text, the late nights and the mind that will not settle point toward insomnia or restless worry, though the poem never says so. The phrase "clear myself" also stands alone for a moment before "of late nights" qualifies it, so for a second the speaker seems to want something larger than a good night's sleep: to be rid of the self that stays up.

The last couplet turns outward: "the stars as high as they seem / sting our hands." The first line sounds like a plain observation, but it is slightly odd. Stars seem impossibly high, and the poem confirms they are as far away as they look. Even so, they sting, and "sting" is a small, bodily, almost insect-like word to attach to something so distant. The s sounds that run through the poem ("some," "stuck," "myself," "stars," "seem," "sting") gather here into a hiss. The pronouns change too. Until now we have had "my mind" and "myself"; suddenly it is "our hands." The private sleeplessness opens into something shared, as though everyone reaching toward the sky, or toward an answer, gets hurt in the same way.

Nothing in the poem is resolved. It has no rhyme scheme, no regular metre and no closing consolation, just four unpunctuated couplets in which each pair of lines lets go of one scale and grabs another: the world, the mind, the self, the cosmos. Its significance lies in that compression. Because the poem leaves out connecting words and explanations, the reader has to supply the links between fragile talk, a stuck committee, wakeful nights and stinging starlight. Each reader will feel the mismatch of scale in their own way, and the poem's final image, a physical sting on the hands, leaves that unease in the body rather than in an argument.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.