Down and out — Poem analysis

I am out of love but only ours which makes the morning a noon

and I am out of doors and poor but will shut my mind

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The title promises a familiar kind of misery. "Down and out" is what we call someone who has lost money, home and standing all at once. Dave Bonta keeps the phrase but pulls it apart, and in six unpunctuated lines the one word "out" gets used for love, for shelter and finally for thought. The poem is about how a private loss can leave a person as stranded as a material one, and about the small, stubborn act of self-protection that follows.

The first stanza begins with an ordinary way of speaking: "I am out of love." We say we are out of milk or out of time, and the phrase makes love sound like a supply that has run dry. Then the second line corrects it: "but only ours." That "only" can read as consolation, since love in general has not vanished. But "ours" turns love into something owned jointly, like a house or an account, and a joint possession is exactly what one person cannot keep alone. Nothing in the text says who ended it or why, and the poem is better for that. The speaker simply reports an absence. The stanza closes on its strangest image: this loss "makes the morning a noon." Morning is the part of the day that holds promise, and noon is the flat, shadowless middle where the day has no more beginning left. The line suggests a day with nothing to wait for, as if the hopeful hours had been skipped. There is a sound pattern here too, with the m of "makes" and "morning" carrying the line forward before it settles into the long, heavy vowel of "noon."

The second stanza moves from feeling to circumstance. "And I am out of doors" repeats the first stanza's structure, so the grammar itself shows one kind of lack leading to another. It can mean literally outside, without a roof, which is where "down and out" was pointing all along. But the old-fashioned phrase "out of doors" also sounds almost pleasant, like a stroll, and the poem lets that mild tone sit uncomfortably beside the harsh fact. Then comes the shortest line, "and poor." It is two syllables long and has no decoration, like a coin set down on a table. The poem never uses the word "down," but the leaning of the lines suggests it, as each one adds a further subtraction.

The last line, "but will shut my mind," carries the poem's weight. The speaker has no door to close, so he closes the one he has left. "Shut" belongs to doors, and it answers "out of doors" with a small, bitter symmetry. Having been locked out of the house, he locks something himself. What he means is open to reading. He may be shutting out memory of the lost love, or refusing to dwell on poverty, or simply switching off thought to get through the day. Because there is no full stop, the sentence stays open in the way a mind is not meant to be, and "will" reads as a decision rather than a certainty. The shutting hasn't happened yet, and the resolve is thin enough that we hear the effort in it. The echo of "makes," "morning," "my" and "mind" ties the last line back to the first stanza, so the closing gesture seems to come from the same hurt.

Formally, the poem is spare. It has two three-line stanzas, no end rhymes and no punctuation. Most of the words are single syllables, and the speech is plain enough to be overheard. Instead of rhyme there is a loose chiming of sounds, with "noon," "doors" and "poor" all leaning on similar long vowels, so that the loss of love, shelter and money sounds like one thing. The line lengths shrink and swell, from the compact "but only ours" to the longer "which makes the morning a noon," and then collapse to "and poor," so the rhythm itself seems to drop and recover.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it does with a worn idiom. It treats heartbreak and destitution as the same condition without announcing the connection, and it ends with a quiet, ambiguous act of will instead of a cry. The speaker has lost nearly everything, and the one thing left to him is the power to close a door.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss