Outcast — Poem analysis

cast the word out word like a hat word I eat at night without any company poor word

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Five lines, no punctuation, not one capital letter: Dave Bonta's "Outcast" looks as if it was dropped onto the page rather than written there. Yet it does something clever before the first line is over. The title is a noun, someone or something thrown aside. The opening line takes that noun apart and turns it into an order: "cast the word out." A fixed label ("outcast") becomes an action in progress. The word being expelled may well be "outcast" itself, so the poem begins by trying to banish its own title.

The attempt doesn't go smoothly. The speaker starts out commanding, but the next lines slide sideways into comparison and appetite. "Word like a hat" is a strange, appealing simile. A hat is something we put on, take off, toss in the air, or hold out for coins, so the comparison suggests that words are worn close to the body and can be thrown away or begged with. Then comes "word I eat." Judging by the phrasing, it's hard not to hear two idioms fused together: "eat your words" (to retract what you said) and "eat your hat." The word the speaker tried to cast out is swallowed instead. Expulsion turns into consumption, and what was rejected goes back inside the body.

The sound and shape of the lines support this. There is no rhyme. Repetition does the work instead: "word" appears four times in five lines, a kind of chant. Say any word that often and it starts to come loose from its meaning and become a bare object, a pebble turned over in the mouth. That suits a poem about handling a word as if it were a physical thing. The rhythm is also uneven in a meaningful way. Lines one, two, three and five are tiny, between two and four syllables. Line four, "at night without any company," runs to eight and is far the longest. The poem stretches out exactly where it describes loneliness, as though the night itself were being measured. The phrase is also slightly odd. "Without company" would have been enough, and the extra "any" adds a flat, total emptiness, with the trailing unstressed syllables of "company" fading like a light going out.

That line also holds the poem's central ambiguity. Who is without company? Because the line follows directly after "word I eat," it could describe the speaker eating alone at night, or the word itself, left friendless. The lack of punctuation lets both readings stand. The speaker who cast out the outcast turns out to share its condition, sitting in the dark with the thing that was supposed to be gone.

Then the last line shifts the tone: "poor word." After a command and a bleak meal, the poem ends in pity, the kind of phrase you might murmur to a stray animal or a hurt child. "Poor" can mean "to be felt sorry for," but also "impoverished," and a word with no company and no use is a poor thing indeed. At two syllables it is the poem's shortest line, so the feeling arrives quietly and the poem simply stops. Without a full stop, nothing is settled either. The speaker neither forgives the word nor finishes expelling it.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it fits into so little space. In a few lines it acts out a whole emotional sequence: rejection, then shame, then the uncomfortable discovery that what we push out of our speech (or our lives) doesn't vanish but returns and has to be digested. It also shows form doing the work of meaning. The title is split open in line one, the repetition mimics obsession, the long fourth line enacts a long night, and the stripped-down ending mirrors the bareness of the word it describes.

For a student, the poem is a useful reminder that a short poem is not a slight one. Its small vocabulary of plain, almost childlike words (hat, eat, night, poor) lets it say something sophisticated about language and loneliness. The most startling thing it suggests is that the speaker's compassion toward the outcast word is also a form of self-recognition.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss