Meadow — Poem analysis

Dave BontaRomantic

meadow like a lush face full of pains and answers

and the ridge where you and I would lie all night

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nothing in Dave Bonta's "Meadow" is explained, and that is where its power comes from. In two short stanzas a field becomes a face, and a hillside becomes a memory, or perhaps a wish. The poem never says which, and it never says what happened on that ridge. What it gives us is a way of looking at land that is really a way of looking at another person.

The central move is the simile in the opening line: "meadow like a lush face." The word "lush" does double duty. For a meadow it means thick, green, overgrown. Applied to a face, it suggests something sensual and fully alive, almost lips and cheeks. Then the second line complicates this by calling the face "full of pains and answers." A meadow in full growth looks abundant, but a face carries history. The grass becomes a surface to be read, like the lines and shadows of someone's expression. The pairing of "pains" with "answers" is the most surprising choice in the poem. We expect pains to sit beside questions, so the missing word hangs in the air. The poem seems to say that these answers are not separate from the hurt, and that what this landscape or person knows was learned through suffering. It leaves the idea unexplained, and so it stays open.

Notice too that the first stanza has no verb. Nothing happens in the meadow. It simply is, and the poem looks at it the way one looks at a loved face, without needing it to do anything. The second stanza adds a verb, but a slippery one: "would lie." That "would" can mean a habit ("we used to lie there") or something imagined ("we would lie there, if we could"). Either way, the grammar puts the lovers at a distance. They are in the past or in the conditional, never plainly in the present. The word "and" that opens the stanza stitches the ridge onto the meadow as if the memory were arriving unbidden, one image pulling the next behind it.

The poem's construction is quietly careful. There is no rhyme, no punctuation and no capital letters, which gives it the feel of a thought still forming. But the syllable count shows more order than first appears. The first stanza's two lines are both six syllables long, balanced like the "pains and answers" they describe. The second stanza starts longer, with seven syllables in "and the ridge where you and I," and then drops sharply to four in "would lie all night." The poem shortens just as it reaches its tenderest moment, as though the speaker's voice thins out. The last line stops without a full stop, and the night is left open-ended.

Sound reinforces this. The long *i* in "I," "lie" and "night" echoes across the last two lines, so the closing phrase has a hushed, sustained hum. Earlier, the soft *l* sounds in "like," "lush" and "full" give the first stanza a lingering quality, as if the speaker were reluctant to move on. Even the ridge may be part of the face metaphor. Judging by the imagery, a ridge is the kind of feature a face has, like a brow or cheekbone, so the speaker and the loved one may be lying on the very face the poem began by describing. That is an inference, not a certainty, but the poem invites it.

What makes "Meadow" worth reading is how much it trusts the reader. It does not tell us whether "you" is a lover, a friend or someone lost, or whether the pains are the speaker's, the other person's or the land's. Instead, it gives us three plain details, a face, a ridge and a night, and lets the gaps do the emotional work. It also shows that a poem does not need length to carry feeling. By treating a landscape as something readable, as intimate as a face, it suggests that the places we have lain beside someone keep their expression long after we have left them.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss