Lotic — Poem analysis

Dave BontaInspired

trim as a ship out of the river present to joy

the river her other self witty with different hands

and visions to express true troubling art

no grief for the body or any private sin

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

"Lotic" is a word from the vocabulary of water science, where it describes things that belong to fast-moving fresh water, such as rivers and streams, as opposed to still ponds. Dave Bonta puts that single word over eight short lines, and it changes how they read. The poem pictures a woman, the only person the pronoun "her" can point to, who is so closely bound to a river that the river becomes "her other self." Its central idea is that a person can feel whole and free when she is in motion, creative and unashamed, with nothing damming her up. The poem does not say who she is, and it is better for that. She is less a character than a condition, a state of being in flow.

The construction supports this. The poem has four couplets, no rhyme, no capital letters and no punctuation at all. More striking still, it contains almost no working verbs. "Trim as a ship," "the river her other self," "visions to express," "no grief for the body" are all fragments that name or describe and never narrate. Nothing is said to happen. This creates a pleasing tension with the title. Water moves, but the grammar holds still, so each couplet seems to sit in the stream like a stepping stone, a complete picture. Without full stops, though, the eye slides from one to the next, and the poem keeps moving.

The imagery begins with a nautical word. "Trim" means neat and tidy, but sailors also speak of a ship's trim, meaning how well it is balanced in the water. The woman is "trim as a ship out of the river," so she is both composed and well balanced. The preposition is odd, since a ship would normally be *on* the river. "Out of" makes her seem to arise from the water, as if she were its product. Then she is "present to joy," a phrase that works two ways. She may be attentive to joy, awake to it, or she may be offered up to it like a gift.

The second couplet makes the doubling explicit: the river is "witty with different hands." Calling a river witty is a fine choice. A current's wit lives in its sudden turns, its eddies, the way it can go around a stone and then over it. The "different hands" suggest many tributaries, but they also bring in craftsmanship, and handwriting, painting and making. That prepares for the third couplet, which turns to "visions to express / true troubling art." The phrase is blunt. The art is not called beautiful or soothing, but "true" and "troubling," and those two words belong together. The stress falls on the repeated *tr* sounds of "true," "troubling," and "trim," a small echo that links the artist to the ship at the poem's opening.

Sound matters throughout. Short *i* sounds run like a ripple through the text: *trim, ship, river, witty, with, different, visions, private, sin*. The last word in that list is the poem's final syllable, which is a quiet irony, because the sound has been used for pleasure all along and ends up attached to the very thing the poem dismisses.

The last couplet is built entirely from absence: "no grief for the body / or any private sin." After three couplets of presence, the poem ends by clearing things away. The body is not a source of grief, and the self is not weighed down by guilt. The word "private" sets up a contrast with the "troubling" art before it. Art may disturb in public, but nothing here is hidden or secret to be ashamed of. One reading is that the river has washed the woman clean. Another, which I think fits the open grammar better, is that she never carried the burden in the first place.

The poem's significance lies in how much it manages in so little space. In under thirty words it builds a portrait, a metaphor and an idea about freedom, and it leaves the reader to fill the gaps. A student might notice that its form acts out its subject: it is unpunctuated and unhurried, and it flows without ever turning into a story. The reader is invited to be "present to joy" in the same way, simply by paying attention.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss