Break — Poem analysis

Dave BontaAnxious

sleeping little I break as anybody would break in pieces infinitely other I am infinitely at sea singing when they sound the depths

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six lines, no punctuation, not a single capital letter: Dave Bonta's "Break" looks as if it has already come apart on the page. The speaker is short of sleep ("sleeping little"), and the poem treats that exhaustion as the start of something larger, a loosening of the self into fragments. Yet the last line does not end in despair. The speaker is "infinitely at sea" and still sings. The central idea is that falling apart can be ordinary, even shared, and that it may release a voice rather than silence one.

Everything begins with the title word, which the poem keeps turning over. "Break" can mean to shatter, to rest, to give way under strain, and it is also what waves do. The poem never says which it means, and the line endings add to the uncertainty. Read one way, the opening is "I break / as anybody would"; read another, the sentence runs on into "anybody would / break in pieces." The word sits at the end of line 1 and again at the start of line 3, and the phrase between them, "as anybody would," is the poem's quietest and most important move. It sounds almost shrugging, like a doctor's reassurance or a friend's. Breaking is presented as a reasonable response to little sleep, not a personal failure. The line break after "break" also enacts what the word describes, since the sentence is cut open and spills over into the next line.

From there the poem widens. "Infinitely other" is a strange phrase, and the strangeness is useful. It suggests that each broken piece is no longer the speaker, or that the speaker has become someone else, and that this happens without limit. A shattered thing is usually described as less than it was, but here the pieces multiply into infinity, so loss turns into a kind of abundance. The word "infinitely" is then repeated in the next line, "I am infinitely at sea," which links the two ideas. "At sea" works literally, because the wave imagery hidden in "break" now surfaces, and idiomatically, because to be at sea is to be confused and without bearings. The punctuation-free syntax lets the lines blur together. "Infinitely other I am infinitely at sea" can be read as one unbroken run, as if the speaker were too tired to stop and mark a sentence's edges.

The poem has no end rhyme and no regular meter. Its short lines move in uneven steps, and the voice stays plain and conversational until the final line. The music is quieter. Long *e* sounds recur in "sleeping," "pieces," "infinitely," and "sea," giving the poem a drifting, watery hum, and soft *s* sounds run through "sleeping," "pieces," "sea," "singing," and "sound." The first and last lines are also linked, since "sleeping" and "singing" are both *-ing* words that begin with *s*. The poem moves from the body's failure to rest to the voice's decision to rise.

The last line carries the most meaning in the fewest words. To "sound the depths" is a sailor's phrase for measuring how deep water is by lowering a weighted line, but "sound" also means noise, and the speaker answers it with singing. Who "they" are is never said. Judging by the imagery, they could be anyone who probes, measures, or tries to understand the speaker's troubles, and the poem declines to name them. The sense is that when others try to measure the speaker's depths, the speaker answers with music. A voice can also "break" into song, and that third meaning of the word seems to be waiting at the poem's end.

"Break" is worth reading because it is small and yet does a great deal. It shows how line breaks, repeated words, and a double-meaning verb can produce the feeling the poem describes. It also resists a familiar story in which suffering must be either hidden or dramatized. The speaker admits to breaking, calls it ordinary, imagines being scattered into countless selves, and stays afloat on a sea with no shore in view. The poem ends before it explains anything, and that restraint leaves the reader with its final image of someone broken into pieces, lost, and singing anyway.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss