Widower — Poem analysis

candlelight on the urn

I hear her song in the highest pitch

and longing for more of her I return to sleep

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A candle, an urn, a voice, a man going back to bed: Dave Bonta's "Widower" offers hardly more than that and leaves the reader to feel the rest. It is about grief at its quietest, not the funeral or the first terrible week, but a private night when the dead woman seems to return and the living man would rather follow her than stay in the room. Its central idea is that longing can outweigh waking life. The widower can only be with his wife where she can still sing, and that place is sleep.

The word "wife" never appears. The title does all the naming. "Widower" tells us who is speaking and what has happened, so the poem itself can say only "her." That pronoun appears twice ("hear her song," "more of her") with no name, no description, no memory of her face. She exists only as a sound and as an absence, and that economy is the poem's method. In twenty-two words, with no punctuation, no capital letters and no rhyme, it moves through three short stanzas. The line lengths vary, from four syllables to seven, so the rhythm is closer to quiet speech than to a counted form, though the compression recalls haiku.

The opening line, "candlelight on the urn," has no verb. Nothing happens in it; it hangs like a photograph or a caption in a stanza of its own. Candlelight is the old light of vigil and remembrance, and the urn suggests, judging by the imagery, that she has been cremated and kept in the house. Light falls "on" the urn, touching its surface but not what it holds. The poem begins by showing us how little of her is left to see.

Then the senses shift from sight to sound: "I hear her song / in the highest pitch." The poem does not say whether this is memory, dream or something half-real, and the plain present tense of "hear" gives the experience full authority. "Highest pitch" is deliberately open. It could be a soprano note, a thin sound at the edge of hearing, or a note stretched to near breaking, as grief is. The sound of the line seems to echo the idea. The long "i" of "candlelight," "I," and "highest" is a bright, narrow vowel that runs through the poem and feels itself high-pitched.

The last stanza turns on its first word. "And longing for more of her" begins with "and," as if the thought had started before the poem did. "Longing" is the poem's only abstract emotional word, and because the stanzas before it have been so concrete, it lands hard. "More of her" is the cruelest phrase in the poem. The urn holds what remains of her body, yet the song is more of her than the ashes are. The grammar also matters. "Longing" is a participle that flows straight into "I return to sleep," so he does not decide to sleep; he is carried there by wanting.

"Return" is a quietly clever choice. It means going back to bed, but it also suggests going back to a familiar place where something is waiting. Say it aloud and it contains "urn," so the sound of the first image comes back inside the last verb. The vowel in "urn" echoes through "her" and "return" as well ("hear her," "of her," "return"), a low, murmuring sound set against the bright "i." The poem's shape is circular and slightly downward: it starts with a candle, a sign of being awake, and ends with sleep. The white space between stanzas works like the silence between notes.

The poem is also careful about what it refuses to say. Sleep can be rest, escape, or a rehearsal for death, and the poem does not choose. It does not say "I want to die" or "I cannot go on." It lets one small act, going back to bed to hear a voice again, suggest how heavy the loss is. That restraint is what makes the poem worth studying. It shows that a very short text can hold a complete emotional movement, from image to sound, from sound to desire, and from desire to action, and that a poem can hurt more by leaving feeling unspoken than by announcing it. The title supplies the grief, the images carry it, and the reader is left in the candlelit room with the widower.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss