Landscape — Poem analysis

Dave BontaRomantic

where I see only you it is as a landscape in the evening with one good horse against the pen

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Twenty words, five lines, no full stop: Dave Bonta's "Landscape" can be read in a single breath, yet it keeps unfolding afterwards. The poem is built around a quiet reversal. We usually say a landscape is like a person, with a face or a mood. Here a person becomes a landscape, and the speaker's love is less a feeling than a way of looking.

The opening line, "where I see only you", sets the terms. "Only" can be read two ways. It may describe the tunnel vision of attachment, in which the rest of the world falls away and one person fills the whole field of view. It may also hint at limitation, since seeing nothing but one person is a kind of narrowing. The poem never decides. Then comes "it is as a landscape". The phrasing is "as a", not the more casual "like a", which gives the comparison a slightly formal, painterly tone, as if the speaker were naming a genre of picture. The pronoun "it" is also slippery. It could refer to the beloved, to the act of seeing, or to the whole scene.

The next details are chosen with great restraint. "In the evening" brings the soft light and lengthening shadows that landscape painters and poets have long loved. It is also the hour when things are gathered in and the day closes. The poem doesn't say whether that mood is peaceful, wistful, or both, but the setting leans toward tenderness. Then the scene is furnished with just one item: "one good horse". The adjective is plain. The horse is not beautiful or wild or magnificent, only *good*, the kind of judgement a person who knows animals might make. The number matters too. In a whole landscape, a single creature is enough to focus the picture and give the emptiness around it a scale.

The last line, "against the pen", is where the poem becomes richest, because "pen" holds two meanings. It can be an enclosure, so the horse stands against the fence of its paddock at dusk, kept in and perhaps safe. It can also be the writing instrument, and then the line suggests the poet's own struggle to hold such a sight in words. "Against" is just as flexible. It might mean silhouetted against, leaning on, or in opposition to. Read the second way, the living horse resists the pen's attempt to capture it, and the poem becomes aware of its own limits as a fence made of language. Because the line has no punctuation, none of these readings is shut out.

The poem's shape supports this openness. There is no rhyme, and the lines shrink in length. Counting syllables, the first two lines run to about six each, and the last three drop to about four. The poem tightens as it goes, much as the view narrows around its single focus. The grammar changes too. The first half contains "I" and "you", two people. The second half has no person at all, only an evening, a horse and a pen. The lovers have dissolved into the picture they describe. The sound shifts along with the sense. The early lines are full of soft sibilants ("see", "is", "as", "landscape"), while the ending closes on firmer sounds, "good horse" and the clipped, stopped "pen". The lowercase, unpunctuated style keeps the voice low and hushed, as though the poet were afraid of startling the thing being watched. Even the capital "I" stands alone, the only capital in the poem, and then disappears.

The poem's significance lies in how much it leaves unsaid. It tells no story and offers no explanation. In a few plain images it suggests that love reshapes perception, that what we love can seem as large and quiet as a country, and that language is both a way of holding such a sight and an enclosure it may not fit inside. The compression recalls the haiku tradition, though that is an inference from its brevity rather than a claim about the poet's intentions. Each reader has to decide whether the horse is safe in its pen or straining against it, and the poem's strength is that both pictures remain possible.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss