Close — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

out on the river someone talking

says the fittest of any might be as likely to die

at the end of our lane the moon

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines, no punctuation, no capital letters, and a whole thought about mortality fits inside them. Dave Bonta's "Close" is built like a scrap of conversation carried across water. We catch it the way the speaker does, partly, without knowing who is talking or why.

The scene is spare. "Out on the river / someone talking": the speaker can't see a face, and the participle "talking" hangs there with no name attached. What drifts across is a remark that the "fittest of any / might be as likely to die." The comparison is left unfinished. As likely as whom? The "as" waits for a partner that never arrives, though we can guess "as anyone." That gap gives the sentence the clipped, half-heard quality of real overheard speech. The central idea is that strength and health are no protection. "Fittest" also carries an echo of "survival of the fittest," a phrase that suggests fitness wins in the end. Here the word is quietly undercut.

The poem then pulls the thought out of the abstract and brings it home. The stanza break after "die" leaves the verb alone for a moment, so the sentence could almost stop there. Then comes "at the end of our lane," and the death that was a general statement acquires an address. The small word "our" does a lot of this work. The speaker belongs to this place, so death is no longer a statistic shouted across the river. It is something that could happen at the edge of home. "End" works twice, as a point on a map and as the end of a life.

The title widens this further. "Close" can be an adjective meaning near, a verb meaning to finish, or, said another way, a word for closeness and intimacy. In British usage a "close" can even be a dead-end street, which would make the title a quiet pun on "the end of our lane." The poem lets all of these meanings sit together, and it also closes itself on the last image.

The sound of the poem supports this. There is no rhyme and no regular meter, only the loose rhythm of speech. The lines swell and then shrink: the middle couplet is the longest, and the final line collapses to two syllables, "the moon," as if a voice were dropping away. Almost every word is plain and short ("out," "on," "says," "die," "lane"). The long vowels in "might," "die," "lane" and "moon" slow the ending down. "Moon" in particular is a round, hushed sound that is hard to say quickly, so the poem comes to rest on it.

That last image is the most interesting choice. "The moon" has no verb and no adjective, and it is grammatically unattached. Is it rising at the end of the lane? Is it simply what the speaker sees while the voice talks of death? Is it a witness? The poem doesn't say. The moon has long been linked with cycles and the passing of time, so it can feel like consolation, a steady and recurring presence, or like indifference, something that shines the same whether anyone lives or dies. Because the poem offers no comment, both readings stay open. The imagery of river, lane and moon also suggests, though it never states, a quiet evening, and that stillness makes the remark about death land harder.

What makes the poem worth reading is this restraint. It has the compression of a haiku without counting syllables. It does not tell us how the speaker feels about what was overheard, and it doesn't moralize about fitness, luck or time. A single half-heard sentence stands in for a large human fact, and the reader supplies the shiver. For a student, it is a good example of how much line breaks, missing punctuation and an unfinished comparison can do. A poem does not need grand language to make us feel how near the end of the lane might be.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Sensei

My teacher resembles a flightless bird: the sky, to him, is an open book written in a foreign tongue, his enormous eyes are no bigger
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss
DreamyDave Bonta

Deconversion

Ice is a house I could not stay in, the answer to a tune I never hear. Tell me how I promise forever