Horse sense — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

horses are testimonies put into flame

a high word is like a false foot easily led either way

I am mixed I move straight and hot

a slave to the office music in the heart

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

"Horse sense" is what we call plain, unshowy practicality, the sort of wisdom that needs no degree. Dave Bonta's poem takes that everyday phrase and sets it on fire. In four unrhymed, unpunctuated couplets, it plays two kinds of knowing against each other: the knowledge that lives in a body and the knowledge that lives in fine-sounding words. Its central idea, as I read it, is that real understanding is something you enact, hot and rhythmic, rather than something you declare.

The first couplet makes the biggest leap: "horses are testimonies / put into flame." A testimony is spoken evidence, a witness's account, and the word often carries a religious ring. Here, though, nothing is said. The testimony has been "put into flame," as though language were turned into heat and muscle. The passive phrasing suggests a translation, words becoming something that gallops. A reader might also catch a faint echo of the fiery horses of biblical story, though that is an inference, not something the poem states. Either way, the horse becomes a witness that speaks by being.

The second couplet gives the only simile: "a high word is like a false foot / easily led either way." "High word" suggests lofty, abstract language, and perhaps also the old sense of "high words" as a quarrel. A "false foot" is a misstep, an unreliable footing. In a poem, "foot" is also the unit of metre, so a false foot could be a faulty beat. That reading is speculative but fits a poem so concerned with rhythm. "Led" brings back the horse, now guided by a bridle, and also suggests that grand language can be steered by anyone toward anything. The line even behaves this way. "Easily led either way" is loose and slides along on soft vowels, with nothing to hold it in place.

Then the speaker steps in: "I am mixed / I move straight and hot." The line "I am mixed" is flat, almost a confession, and it can mean several things. Mixed feelings, mixed ancestry, part human and part animal, or simply impure, not a clean example of anything. The next line resolves the confusion by moving. "Straight and hot" is all hard, clipped monosyllables, with no hesitation in the sound. "Hot" answers "flame" from the first couplet, so the speaker has borrowed the horses' fire. The paradox is deliberate. The speaker is divided but travels in a straight line, as if action settles what thought cannot.

The ending is the strangest turn: "a slave to the office music / in the heart." After the speed of the third couplet, "slave" is a shock. "Office" is wonderfully double. It can mean the workplace and its dull, droning routines, or a religious office, the fixed prayers a person is bound to keep. Either way, it is a repeating duty. But this music sits "in the heart," which suggests the heartbeat, and a heartbeat sounds much like hoofbeats. The freedom of the horse turns out to be obedience, not to the "high word" that can be led anywhere but to an inner rhythm that cannot be argued with. The final line, "in the heart," is the shortest in the poem, and it lands like a beat.

The form supports this. With no rhyme and no punctuation, the poem leans on white space, short lines and the push of its images. The lack of punctuation also leaves some phrases open to more than one reading, which is exactly the "either way" quality the second couplet distrusts. The poem might be quietly aware that it is made of words too, and so it relies on rhythm and image more than on statement.

That tension is what makes it worth reading. It is a tiny ars poetica, a poem about the limits of poetic language that still trusts its pulse. It also challenges the easy idea that freedom and servitude are opposites. For students, it shows how much a poem can do by reopening a worn-out idiom and letting its double meanings, "foot" and "office," do the heavy lifting. Horse sense, here, is not common sense but a wisdom that burns, moves and keeps time.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss