High — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

in a high place the promise of utmost ruin

my tent all alone

I am air and light only I think

I have this one day

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Four lines, no punctuation, no capital letters, and in that small space a whole mountain-top experience: danger, solitude, a loosening of the self, and a deadline. Dave Bonta's "High" is about what happens to a person who goes somewhere exposed and finds that the exposure is also a kind of freedom. Its central idea is that awareness of ruin, whether a fall, a storm or simply the end of things, doesn't cancel the value of the moment. It sharpens it.

The first line is the longest and the heaviest. "In a high place the promise of utmost ruin" runs to about twelve syllables, and the later lines shrink to five, nine and five, as if the speaker's burden grows lighter as the poem climbs. The word "promise" is a clever choice. We expect promises to be good, yet this one is "of utmost ruin." The high place seems to offer destruction the way a cliff edge or an exposed ridge does, as a standing possibility. Notice, too, that "high" and "utmost" are both words of extremity, so the line is stacked with superlatives before anything human appears. The title adds a second possibility. "High" can also mean exhilarated, and by the end that meaning has crept in, because the speaker's mood is lifted even as the setting stays threatening.

Then comes the human scale: "my tent all alone." There is no verb, just a fragment, and the grammar makes the tent feel as bare as the thing itself. A tent is the opposite of ruin's permanence, a shelter that can be folded away by morning. It is also tiny set against the "high place" of line one. The sounds tell a story here. "Alone," "only" and "one" belong to the same family of words. "Alone" began as "all one," and "only" is "one-ly." Across the poem this chain tightens from "all alone" through "only" to "this one day," moving from loneliness toward a single, concentrated unit of time.

The third line is the poem's strangest and best. "I am air and light only I think" can be read two ways because there is no punctuation to settle it. One reading is "I am air and light only, I think," where the speaker hedges: perhaps I have dissolved into the thin atmosphere. The other lets "only I think" hang together, suggesting that thinking is all that remains of the speaker. The ambiguity does real work. The statement is bold, a person claiming to be weightless, but "I think" makes it modest and a little comic, as if the speaker is checking whether the feeling is real. The long "i" sounds support the blur between self and sky. "High," "my," "light," "I" and "I" echo each other, so the pronoun seems to dissolve into the very air it describes.

The ending drops to plain, short words: "I have this one day." Every word is a single syllable, and after the abstractions of ruin and air, the voice becomes almost bare. The verb "have" matters. Against "the promise of utmost ruin" it sounds like possession, even a quiet defiance. The speaker doesn't say "I have only one day," which would sound like complaint. "This one day" is a gift held in the hand. The tent explains why: this is a trip with a clear limit, and the limit gives the time its intensity.

There is no rhyme and no regular meter, and that suits the content. A rhyme scheme would bring a tidy resolution, and the poem refuses one, ending on a fact rather than a flourish. Its economy may remind some readers of haiku, though it follows no fixed form that I would claim for it. The white space does what a longer poem would do with description. We supply the wind, the cold and the drop beyond the tent.

What makes "High" worth reading is its trust in the reader. It never says what the ruin is, or why the speaker climbed, or what the speaker feels beyond that hesitant "I think." Instead it sets danger, smallness, weightlessness and time next to each other and lets them interact. Many of us live as if we had unlimited days. This poem, in about twenty words, imagines having exactly one and finding that enough.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss