Cow — Poem analysis

Dave BontaContemplative

field cow like another country

not stirring even to off a fly

where I see air it sits with the dead

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A cow in a field, doing nothing: that is the whole event of Dave Bonta's "Cow", and the poem's quiet trick is to make that nothing feel enormous. In six short lines a speaker watches an animal so motionless that it stops looking like an animal and starts looking like a place, and then like something nearer to death than to life. The central idea is the strangeness of stillness. An ordinary creature, looked at long enough, becomes unreachable.

The opening couplet does a great deal with very little. "Field cow" is two nouns pushed together with no article and no verb, like a label or a note jotted down in the grass. It could be a type of cow, or a cow so much a part of the field that the two have fused. Then comes the poem's only simile, and it is an odd one. A motionless thing might be "like a stone" or "like a hill", but the cow is "like another country". A country has borders, a language you don't speak, a landscape you can look at but not enter. The cow is foreign to the speaker, and the hard *c* sounds of "cow" and "country" quietly tie the two together. Death may slip in here too, since "country" can faintly recall the phrase "the undiscovered country" from Shakespeare's *Hamlet*, though the poem never says so.

The second couplet defines the cow by what it refuses to do. "Not stirring even / to off a fly": the line break leaves "even" hanging, so the reader waits just as the speaker waits for movement that never comes. Then "off" is used as a verb, which is the poem's neatest move. To "off" a fly can mean to brush it away, but in slang it also means to kill. The cow won't even do that much, and the word has already brought a whiff of death into the scene. The fly is the only thing moving in the poem, and judging by the imagery it carries a hint of decay, since flies gather around what has stopped living.

The last couplet is where the poem turns strange. "Where I see air / it sits with the dead." The speaker appears for the first time, and what he sees is "air", as if his gaze passes straight through the cow. The pronoun "it" is ambiguous. It might be the cow, so still that it dissolves into emptiness and joins the dead. It might be the air itself, the visible nothing where the dead are imagined to gather. The poem doesn't choose, and both readings work. The verb helps too. Cows stand or lie down, but "sits" is a human word, and "sitting with the dead" suggests keeping vigil at a deathbed or a wake. The cow becomes a kind of mourner, or a member of the company it watches over.

The form matches this restraint. There are three couplets, no rhyme and no punctuation at all, not even a full stop at the end. Nothing chimes or resolves, so the poem simply stops, as the cow's stillness presumably goes on. The lines are short, with two or three stresses each. "Field cow" puts two heavy beats side by side, slowing the reader at the start, and the final line is five plain monosyllables landing on the thudding "dead". Soft sibilants run through the middle ("stirring", "sits", "see", "air"), giving a hushed, watchful sound. The compression recalls haiku, although the poem follows no syllable count.

What makes "Cow" worth reading is how far it travels on such plain materials. It begins as a rural snapshot and ends at the border between the living and the dead, without ever raising its voice. It also avoids sentimentality: the cow is not gentle or picturesque, only indifferent and apart. For a student looking for something to hold on to, the poem rewards attention to three small things: one simile ("another country"), one pun ("off"), and one slippery pronoun ("it"). Each opens a door onto something larger than a cow in a field.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss