Displaced — Poem analysis

weather like a committee in the ear of the land

tell me how to lose a place which was taken from me

and with what cross and with whose grave

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines carry the whole grievance of "Displaced," and the poem never says where it happens or who is to blame. It is about the gap between what is done to a person and what that person is then expected to do about it. The central idea sits in the poem's one paradox: "tell me how to lose a place / which was taken from me." Losing is something you do, or at least allow. Being taken from is something done to you. The speaker asks to be taught a kind of acceptance that the facts do not permit.

The opening image sets a cold, bureaucratic mood. "Weather like a committee / in the ear of the land" is a strange comparison. Weather is usually elemental and wordless, and committees are slow, procedural and faceless. Putting them together makes the forces that push people off their ground sound both natural and administrative, as if a decision had been murmured into the landscape and nobody could be found who made it. The land is given an ear, so it can be lobbied and persuaded, and the speaker is left outside the conversation. The poem says nothing about whether the "weather" is literal or political, and the ambiguity is useful. Displacement can come from storms and from policies, and the poem lets the two blur.

Then the voice turns personal. "Tell me how" is grammatically a command, but there is no question mark, and the poem has no punctuation or capital letters at all. That lack of punctuation makes the request sound flat, tired, almost beyond anger. The speaker is not shouting. The slightly formal "which was taken from me," chosen over a plainer "that," adds a note of dignity, as though the speaker were stating a legal fact for the record.

The last couplet changes the poem's vocabulary. "And with what cross / and with whose grave" brings in religious and funereal language. A cross can be carried, which makes it a burden, and it can also mark a grave. A grave is where grief has somewhere to go. Together they suggest that losing something properly takes ritual: a suffering to shoulder and a place to mourn. The speaker asks with what cross and whose grave because a stolen place offers neither. There is no body to bury and no ceremony for the loss. The repeated "and with" gives the lines a stubborn, liturgical rhythm, like someone listing what they are owed. "Whose grave" is the most open phrase in the poem. It could mean the dead who stay behind in the lost place, or a grave the speaker can no longer visit, or the speaker's own.

The sound of the poem supports this. There is no rhyme, and the couplets are held together by rhythm and echo instead. The lines shrink as they go: seven syllables in "weather like a committee," six in "in the ear of the land," then seven and six again, and finally two lines of only four syllables. "Committee" is long and soft, a word that seems to murmur. By the end the language has been reduced to blunt monosyllables, "cross" and "grave," with hard consonants that close like a door. A quiet breath of w-sounds runs through the poem, in "weather," "which," "was," "with," "what," "with," "whose." It sounds like wind, or like whispering, so the committee's murmur never quite leaves the poem even after the speaker starts to speak.

The poem is significant for how much it refuses. It gives no place name, no villain and no story, and so it fits many kinds of loss while keeping its edge. Its brevity is part of the argument, because there is no room for consolation. The closing couplet is not an answer and not even a complete question, since both lines trail off after their small prepositional phrases. The reader is left with the speaker's problem, which is how to grieve something that was never freely given up.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.