Has-been — Poem analysis

times now gone took me and all my ink with them

I shall employ some puppet to see for me

and a bottle of wine in my pocket through dark weather

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Few people call themselves a has-been without wincing, and the speaker of Dave Bonta's six-line poem manages to wince and grin at once. The label is usually pinned on someone by others, a small cruelty. Here it is claimed from the inside, as if the speaker would rather say the worst thing first and get on with it. What follows is a short inventory of what is left: a puppet, a bottle of wine, some dark weather.

The first couplet sets the loss in motion: "times now gone took me / and all my ink with them." The grammatical subject is not "I" but "times," past eras personified as something that can walk off with a person the way a tide or a thief might. The speaker is only the object of the verb, carried away. "Ink" is a precise choice. It is not "talent" or "inspiration" but a physical, dark, messy substance, the stuff a writer puts on the page, and the word hints at lifeblood as well. "All" leaves no hope of a remainder.

Then the grammar flips. "I shall employ some puppet / to see for me." The "I" finally arrives, along with a mock-dignified "shall," the diction of a minor lord arranging his household. The speaker is diminished but still giving orders. The puppet is the strangest image in the poem and the most open. A puppet has no will or eyes of its own and moves only when a hand is inside it, so asking it to "see" is faintly absurd. Judging by the text, it could be a persona, a mask through which a used-up writer keeps looking at the world at second hand. It could equally be a stand-in of some other kind. The poem doesn't decide, and the casual "some puppet" suggests the speaker isn't fussy. Any puppet will do.

The last couplet is "and a bottle of wine in my pocket / through dark weather." It has no verb of its own. The word "and" hitches it to the previous sentence, as though puppet and wine were two items on one packing list. That looseness gives the speaker an offhand, travelling air, a journey begun without much planning. The wine is a pocket-sized consolation, and it quietly answers the lost ink: one dark liquid replaces another, the first for making marks, the second for getting through. "Dark weather" can be read literally, as rain on the road, or as the speaker's mood. The poem leaves both open. The final line is the shortest and slowest, three words with nothing to hurry them, and it ends on enduring rather than recovering.

The form matches this mood. The poem is three unrhymed couplets with no punctuation, no capital letters and no full stop. Because nothing closes, the poem doesn't finish so much as trail off into the weather, still moving. Every couplet breaks mid-thought ("took me / and all my ink," "puppet / to see," "pocket / through dark weather"), so each pair of lines tips forward into the next. There is no rhyme, but sound still links things. "Puppet" and "pocket" sit in the same place in their couplets and share their outline of consonants, a near-echo that puts the two props side by side. "Me" ends both the first and the fourth lines. At first it names the one who was taken, and later the one being served, so a single small word marks the shift from victim to commander.

The poem's significance lies in a paradox. A writer announces that his ink is gone, and the announcement is itself a finished poem. The has-be

en is still producing, and the poem's wit and compression refuse self-pity. It makes a modest case that resourcefulness outlasts confidence. When the old way of seeing is gone, you improvise a puppet, pocket a bottle and walk out anyway. For a reader, much of the pleasure comes from what is left unexplained, because the poem trusts a few concrete objects to carry a whole attitude toward loss.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Fairy Bells

Prosartes lanuginosa Their ringing isn’t obvious; you need the ear of an anchorite to find them.
CheerfulDave Bonta

Homunculus

Within my mind a mind I long to tame— a left boy, a little Hercules, the king of ham.