DREAMER — Poem analysis

I spent my tomboy girlhood on horses rambling through orchards & the molehills we fancied mountains, just south of the glacier’s plow line. My brothers taught me all the arcana of knots & hitches I call to mind now, tied to an oxygen tank, the transparent umbilicus bridled to my nostrils.

The man I married grew up in town & loved the country for its range of practical puzzles. But for my part, I preferred the ocean’s implausible clues: polished stones & glass & wood on a beach asymptotic to the hyperbole of waves, tidepool anemones like stars collapsing, turning inward, conch & clamshell pressing their ears to the sand.

All the men of my family were hardheaded Methodists for whom speech was more vital than prayer. But I always found piety jarring–the minister’s baited candy. Like the scent of a bear in the barn one day as I rode my favorite Clydesdale in, standing barefoot on his back like a circus performer, reins in one hand. When that massive draft horse shied he sent me flying, really flying, ponytailed hair & calico skirts ballooning.

My sister & I were like that: we smoked, we drank a little, we rode along behind on our brothers’ motorcycles. But when it came time to marry, we did. Hank & I settled in calm suburban waters, had three sons– if I’d had a daughter, I wouldn’t have known what to do! And when he retired, we bought a small house on the ocean, ‘way down south– a house built on sand, true, but protected by seawalls from the storm surge

until these last couple years when everything got me at once, & the songs my mother sang to me in the crib suddenly after all this time pop into my head. It’s as if you were to find a bottle, say, on the high tide’s windrow–& the message inside were written in your own hand, in childish shaky letters. I just lie here humming & wondering where I’ve been.

I’m in pain, of course, but it’s not so bad that they have to take me out back & shoot me just yet! The main thing is, my mind’s still clear, neither too fast nor too slow. Makes me think of my favorite Robert Burns song, do you know it? “Flow Gently Sweet Afton.”

Well, we don’t need to sing the whole thing now. There’ll be plenty of time later, when I’m gone.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

An old woman lies connected to an oxygen tank and, instead of complaining, tells us where she has been. That is the whole situation of "Dreamer," and its central idea is that a life, even a conventional one, ends up as a story the dying person must piece together, and that she can face the ending with humour and nerve. Dave Bonta gives her a voice so relaxed and so full of farm-country idiom that we almost miss how much the poem is doing underneath.

The opening shows the method. She recalls learning "all the arcana of knots & hitches" from her brothers, then mentions that she recalls them "now, tied to an oxygen tank, / the transparent umbilicus bridled to my nostrils." The horse language is quietly cruel: she was once the rider holding the reins, and now she is the animal in the tack. "Umbilicus" turns the tube into a birth cord, so the end of life loops back to its beginning. The poem keeps making this kind of loop.

The second stanza sets her against her husband. He loved the country for its "practical puzzles"; she preferred the sea's "implausible clues." The sea she describes is full of strange, half-mathematical images: a beach "asymptotic to the hyperbole of waves" (a line that approaches the water without ever quite touching it), anemones "like stars collapsing, turning inward," shells "pressing their ears to the sand." The collapsing stars anticipate her failing body, and the listening shells anticipate the way she will later lie quietly and hear her mother's songs. She has always been someone who reads messages in things.

Her brief flight from the Clydesdale is the poem's most vivid memory. Standing barefoot on the horse's back, she is thrown when it smells a bear, and she is "really flying, / ponytailed hair & calico skirts ballooning." The word "really" lets the old woman relish a moment she is still proud of, and the image also works as a rehearsal for death: a thrilling loss of ground. Notice that it follows her remark about her Methodist family, "for whom speech was more vital than prayer." She distrusts piety (the minister's "baited candy"), yet her own speech, the monologue we are hearing, becomes the poem's nearest thing to a sacrament.

The form supports this plain-spoken tone. There is no rhyme and no regular meter; the lines are long and conversational, and the ampersands make the speech feel jotted down rather than polished. Stanzas vary in length, as a rambling talker's would. Line breaks sometimes deliver dry understatement: "But when / it came time to marry, we did." The flatness is the point, because the choice was barely a choice. Her house on the sand is "protected by seawalls from the storm surge" and then the sentence spills over the stanza break into "until these last couple years when everything / got me at once." The white space is where the wall gives way.

What breaks through is memory itself: her mother's lullabies, which return like a bottle on the "high tide's windrow" with a message "written in your own hand, / in childish shaky letters." The image is lovely because the shakiness of a child learning to write and of an old person losing control of the pen is the same shakiness. She "just lie[s] here humming & wondering where I've been."

The ending refuses to become sentimental. She jokes that she isn't yet bad enough to be taken "out back & shoot[ed]," the way a farm animal might be, then offers Burns's "Flow Gently Sweet Afton," a song whose refrain asks the river not to disturb a sleeper's dream. That explains the title, though the poem never uses the word "dream" itself. Her last move is to decline to sing: "There'll be plenty of time later, when I'm gone." It is funny, brave and unsettling, and it leaves the song, like the rest of her life, half told. That is the poem's significance: it lets an ordinary life be strange, and lets death be a conversation rather than a speech.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss