The Secret — Poem analysis

They cannot know a secret that I know, The city dwellers with their leaden eyes, Caught like a leaf in traffic’s ebb and flow, Deafened by all a city’s raucous cries; They cannot know it in the canyons there Where steel and stone deflect a mortal’s stare.

For I arose before the moon went down, Half-way toward morning. Dew-wet lay the world, And, in the sunrise, brighter than the town. Deep in the valley’s hush I found uncurled A bloodroot flower; I touched it with my hand, And I alone know spring is on the land.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Nobody in Daniel Whitehead Hicky's "The Secret" is told anything. The poem is built on a refusal: there is a piece of knowledge, and the speaker keeps it. The city dwellers "cannot know" it, and by the end the speaker declares, "I alone know spring is on the land." What looks at first like a small nature lyric turns out to be about who gets to notice the world, and what it costs to stay in a place that stops you noticing.

The first stanza sets up the opposition with some sharp choices of language. The city people have "leaden eyes", and lead is the heaviest, dullest of metals, so the phrase suggests eyes that no longer reflect light or look up. They are "caught like a leaf in traffic's ebb and flow," a simile that is quietly ironic. A leaf is the very thing that should mark the changing seasons, yet here it is swept along helplessly, stripped of its natural meaning and reduced to debris in a current of cars. Even the sounds of the city are aggressive: they are "deafened" by its "raucous cries." The stanza ends in the "canyons" of the streets, "where steel and stone deflect a mortal's stare." The verb "deflect" is the cleverest word here. The buildings don't merely block the view; they bounce the gaze away, so that a person's attention can never settle on anything alive.

The second stanza answers this with a change of scene and a change of tempo. The speaker "arose before the moon went down, / Half-way toward morning," and the sentence stops and starts, with short phrases and full stops mid-line ("Dew-wet lay the world."), as if the speaker were walking slowly and taking things in. Details of touch and light replace the noise of the first stanza: the dew, the "sunrise, brighter than the town," the "valley's hush." Notice that the speaker's world is also measured against the city here, since the sunrise is "brighter than the town," so the town is still present as a rival. Then comes the discovery, a "bloodroot flower," which is "uncurled," a word that makes the plant seem like something waking up. The speaker's gesture, "I touched it with my hand," is the emotional centre of the poem. It is plain and physical, the exact opposite of the deflected stare in the first stanza.

The form supports this contrast. Each stanza is six lines with the rhyme scheme ABABCC, a pattern that moves forward in alternating rhymes (know / flow, eyes / cries) and then closes with a rhyming couplet (there / stare; hand / land). The couplets work like a click of a latch at the end of each stanza, and they land the two key statements: the city "deflects" the stare, and the speaker alone knows spring has come. The lines are regular iambic pentameter, a measured, traditional beat that gives the poem a calm, confident tone. That calm is part of the point, since the speaker's attitude is not angry at the city but quietly sure of having something better.

Yet the poem's ending leaves a small question hanging. "I alone know" is a proud claim, and it raises the possibility that the speaker's pleasure depends partly on being superior to everyone else. A secret that cannot be shared is also a kind of loneliness. The poem never says whether the speaker regrets this, and the ambiguity is what keeps it interesting rather than merely pretty.

What makes "The Secret" worth reading is how much it does in twelve lines. It makes a familiar argument, that nature is something the busy modern world has forgotten how to see, but it makes it through concrete detail rather than preaching: leaden eyes against a single uncurled flower, a deflected stare against a hand reaching out. The bloodroot is small and easy to miss, and that is exactly the point.

Read also

More by Daniel Whitehead Hicky

All poems
InspiredDaniel Whitehead Hicky

Dawn Fishermen: Key West

Slowly, a shadow’s length this side of day, The small boats edge to sea with less of sound Than the wind takes to lift a cloud of spray. In salty blackness now the fishing ground
ContemplativeDaniel Whitehead Hicky

Iris Are Not for Children

Iris are not for children laughing, playing, Nor jonquils with their cups of yellow fire. These colors belong to April and the old Whose veins no longer blossom with desire,
ContemplativeDaniel Whitehead Hicky

December Night

Through all this frozen night there is no sound Save my white footsteps on a whiter ground, No stir up from the meadow, nor the brake Lost in the whitening wind beyond the lake.