Silence — Poem analysis

Today it seemed As tho' I walked Kneedeep in prayer, As one may tread Thru summer grass, Yet everywhere The silence grew. No winging words Mute lips did part. The hush of noon Lay on the land That is my heart.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Few poems say so much in so few words. In twelve short lines, Elizabeth von Schonberg describes a single afternoon's walk that is really a walk through the speaker's own spiritual state. Nothing happens in the usual sense: no event, no argument, no visitor. What the poem gives us instead is a feeling, and the work of the whole piece is to make that feeling precise. The feeling is prayer that has gone quiet, a devotion that continues even though no words come.

The central image arrives in the opening lines, where the speaker seems "Kneedeep in prayer, / As one may tread / Thru summer grass." It is a surprising comparison, because we normally think of prayer as something done in stillness, perhaps kneeling. Here it becomes a medium to move through, like a meadow. The word "kneedeep" quietly does double duty: it describes wading through tall grass, but it also echoes the posture of kneeling, so that the body is both walking and bowed at once. The grass is soft and warm and plentiful, and so, the simile suggests, is the prayer: abundant, surrounding, almost effortless. Notice too the hedge in "it seemed / As tho' I walked." The speaker does not claim to be praying; she reports that it felt that way, which gives the whole poem a hushed, tentative honesty.

Then comes the turn, signalled by "Yet." Everywhere she walks, "the silence grew." The verb matters. Silence here is not an absence but something alive, spreading like the grass itself, and the poem's two main images begin to merge: prayer and silence are the same landscape. The next lines make this explicit and strange. "No winging words / Mute lips did part." The inversion of normal word order slows the reader down, and the phrase "winging words" is lovely, because it pictures speech as birds leaving the mouth. Here none take flight. The lips are "mute", which means they are not forbidden to speak so much as simply have nothing to say. One can read this as spiritual dryness, a failure of language before God, but the surrounding imagery of summer and noon pushes against that reading. This silence feels full rather than empty.

The final three lines settle the matter. "The hush of noon / Lay on the land / That is my heart." Noon is the stillest hour of a summer day, when shadows shorten, birdsong fades, and heat presses the world flat. By laying that hush over the speaker's heart, the poem reveals that the landscape was inward all along. The earlier "land" and "summer grass" were never just scenery; they were the heart seen as terrain. The last line delivers this with a plain, almost startled directness, and it is the only place where the poem names its real subject.

The form supports this effect. The lines are very short, mostly three or four syllables, so the poem moves in tiny, careful steps, much like someone walking slowly through high grass. The rhythm is loose and unhurried rather than strictly metrical, and the rhyme is sparing: "grew" and the near-echo of "part" and "heart" arrive late, with "heart" landing as the final, quiet chord. Because the rhymes are so sparse, the ear notices them, and the closing rhyme of "part" with "heart" feels like a door gently clicking shut. The poem also practises what it describes. Its brevity, its white space, and its refusal to elaborate are a kind of silence made visible on the page.

What makes the poem significant is its quiet paradox: it uses words to evoke the absence of words, and it treats that absence as a form of prayer rather than a failure of it. It suggests that devotion need not be eloquent, and that the deepest moments may be those in which speech falls away. For a student reader, it is a good lesson in how much a poem can do with restraint, and how a single, well-chosen image, the heart as noonday land, can carry an entire emotional experience.

Read also

More by Elizabeth von Schonberg

All poems
RomanticElizabeth von Schonberg

Strategy

What did you say, my darling, When you spoke to me, just then? “I said that today I love you more Than yesterday or the day before."
RomanticElizabeth von Schonberg

Constancy

Your eyes—deep wells of blueness Reflect the steady flame That is your gentle spirit, Is Constancy your name?
RomanticElizabeth von Schonberg

Spring Flowers

I found your box of flowers at my door And knew they were from you even before I raised the lid and saw the loveliness That touched me like a summer wind's caress!